Mike's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

474 Avenue C, Bayonne - 07002
74 reviews
Pizza Italian
(201) 437-9550

Best pizza gem!Try the pineapple jalapeño pizza and the potato wedges, great customer service! Too bad they're close on sundays..

After I found this place, it's my absolute favorite. I usually order pizza, burgers, or chicken tenders for my kids, but for me? ALWAYS the chicken Caesar salad. It's my go-to, and every time I call, I know I'm being taken care of. Food is always delicious, always delivered by great, courteous delivery guys, and I've never ordered anything my family didn't enjoy. Great job to everyone at Mike's, and I'll continue to order my favorite salad whenever I can!

Had a fantastic meal of shrimp scampi paid for by Victor and company and the owner seems to treat ladies like princesses. Hopefully my previous street sense is correct. Wish YOUZ well. Sorry if you interrupt it wrong. No disrespect intended. Raised very well.

Fried chicken was dry. Pizza had no taste.

Horrible experience ask for chicken wrap with no onions and they put onions on it the food was cold and they where really rude I called multiple times saying if they got my number wrong and he said no multiple times the delivered came late was completely rude and forgot to send part of the order.

Best pizza in town and they make a good burger with great fries. Good prices, good delivery service

I would like to note that this has been our Go To pizza place until our past two orders resulted in my husband ad I getting sick in the stomach. The last order I think I learned the reason why. I found a piece of metal wire from what I can assume came from their brillo cleaning sponge in the pizza. And when I say found, I mean I pulled out from my mouth as it must have been in the dough. I understand things can happen but this restaurant needs to take better precautions when cleaning their materials (pans) to ensure this doesn't happen again. It's sad because this has been our Go-To pizza place since moving to Bayonne but two bad experiences back to back is enough for us to no longer want to order from them again. Hopefully this doesn't happen to anyone else.

Pizza was ok. Was better when I asked for my slices extra crispy.

This was my first time ordering from Mikes and it was great! The portions are extremely generous considering the price. Everything tasted good, the only bad thing I have to say is the I ordered half pepperoni on my pizza but got all cheese. Besides that it was a great experience and if you’re hesitant you should definitely buy from here! Delivery was also quick!

Awesome food at reasonable prices. Tends to be busy on weekends so plan accordingly. Pizza selections have always been satisfying. The chicken parm, eggplant parms are good yet tend to be quite salty