Old Homestead Steak House

1 Borgata Way, Atlantic City - 08401
286 reviews
Steak House American Wine Bar
(609) 317-1000

Best filet I have ever eaten. Everything was delicious.

Everything I thought it would be! Great ambiance,customer service and romantic asffff.

Love it there, great ambiance and steak was on point…like the way I like med rare!!!

All the soup bread and salad are amazing the salad portion was huge and was a very good house salad however the steak is slightly disappointing it does not even have a flavor on it not even a hint of salt I think it might be ours that got mess up but I don't know since that's the first time there and we saw all the other food other table ordered they all looked delicious I would have to say overall just the steak everything else was amazing

Fantastic experience. Jeff and Chip were top notch! I asked for bottle of wine to be opened prior to arriving to let it breathe. We arrived with a decanter on table .. and a smile on Jeffs face. He made everything special and the food was delicious. The Salmon was delicious and the steak was incredible. Shrimp cocktail were huge and fresh.

This place was absolutely incredible. Stellar service and the food was worth every penny. The atmosphere was wonderful and our server was great. This restaurant is a must visit.

Love this place. Service and food are excellent. We had a shrimp cocktail and it was as good as any I have had. Ordered the Wagu sirloin steak to share with my wife for $175 it was tender but fatty and I would not get this again or recommend this dish. Everything else was excellent and I have had the filet there before and it was very good. Overall I highly recommend this place.

We were so looking forward to a lovely evening at this A rated restaurant. As soon as we entered there were a bunch of convention people speaking so loudly in the very small bar area that it actually immediately gave me a headache. We waited approx. 5 minutes until seated, and was brought up to the second floor, I thought this would be quieter. Oh! Was I wrong, besides still hearing the crowd downstairs, the group of six in the table next to us was also very loud. So far very disappointed, I couldn't hear my spouse speak. When the server told us the specials it was very hard to hear him. Now for the good news, my wine was great, spouses vodka gimlet was first class. Spouse ordered salad wedge great blue cheese, not enough bacon and lettuce piece was quite dense. I ordered the onion soup, good taste, didn't like the bread they used, it became so soggy. Spouse ordered prime rib, was so tender it melted in the mouth. Only thing I have to say is it was so large he couldn't eat it all and since we were staying in the hotel it was a real shame for the rest to go in the garage. I hate to see food wasted. I ordered th Chilean sea bass, it was absolutely out of this world!! I made the best choice!!! I would recommend this entree to everyone!!! All and all the food was great, but the over all enjoyment of our dinner was disappointing.

Good service, very nice staff. Food is good. Side portions are big,, like the mashed potatoes and salad. Did not love the crème brûlée, I had better. The place is loud with everyone celebrating!

My family and I agreed to take in a show and dinner at the Borgata. We chose the Old Homestead Steakhouse based on previous reviews and reputation. We were wrong. The food was better than average but could not compare to the steakhouses in Vegas nor any of Ruby’s steakhouses in Cincinnati (of which I have been to all of them). All members of the party agreed the food was good but not memorable. However, the one area we all agreed on was the service really sucked for this level of restaurant. No one approached the table for a second round of drinks or asked us if there was any interest in another round of bread, which there was. A salad was ordered and plopped on the table after the server was told that I was the one who ordered it and it just sat there until I served myself. The standard efforts of clearing the dishes seemed to be an afterthought. I can go on and on regarding expectations but the following sums it up…. I get better services at Texas Roadhouse than I did here. So in my humble opinion, save your hard earned money or lower your expectations when going to this establishment.