Was pleasantly surprised by this establishment. First time here and the food was delicious. Fresh and hot. Our server was great. Appetizer for two meatballs was $7.99 and our two main dishes was $14.99 each. Definitely a place I will return to and order again. Leftovers were delicious the next day.
Used to be very good. Seems that nothing is made in house anymore. Pizza sauce obviously from a can. Heard another table talking about the meat sauce has no meat. Flavors bland. I don't mind paying more as long as the quality stays top notch. And a shorter menu? Just not what it used to be, sorry.
Stefanina's of Wentzville, Missouri is one of our top 5 restaurants because of the friendly atmosphere of management and waitstaff, and the Wednesday night "buy a large pizza for a small price" has to be one of the best meal deals anywhere.My wife and I always bring home half of our large pizza, and she makes a salad at home for a whole other meal.Stefanina's pizza is really worth the dough, especially their crust. When you reheat the pizza at 350 degrees for 7 to 10 minutes, the pizza tastes almost as good the second time as when it was first served by Stefanina's waitstaff the first time, straight out of the oven. ?
Food is good here. However, we came tonight 03/05/2022 and 20 minutes after being seated we hadn't been served or even asked our drink orders. Other tables around us received service while we did not. We left and went elsewhere.
We ordered from the catering menu for approximately 20 people. The food was delivered at the exact time and very hot. The lasagna and toasted ravioli were delicious. We will definitely use them again for catering.
Ordered online. Food was ready at the time expected. Great service. If you haven't tried the Alfred pizza, I highly recommend it. We got ours without bacon but it usually comes with.
There food was amazing! We had a awesome person waiting on us to. Very attentive
We had been in the house for days and decided to go to dinner at the tail end of a snow storm. All restaurants in the area were closed but Stefanina's was open. Short staffed but open. We were greeted and seated with a comment about being short staffed but we understood with the snow. The place was packed with one server. The waitress promptly got our drink and apps order and before we decide what to eat our drinks and apps were on the table. The service was fantastic staff outstanding and food was delicious and warm. This is a long standing member of the Wentzville community standing the test of time and again every chain restaurant that pops up to try and take it's place.
The biggest chef salad and the meat pizza were awesome. Friendly staff and clean dining area.
Their food is great - but I will most likely never eat their pizza again. Found a metal wire (from a wire bristle brush probably used to clean their ovens) in my pizza. So thankful I didn’t swallow it and even MORE thankful my toddler didn’t swallow it as he was eating on the same pizza. I can’t even begin to fathom the damage that would have done. I was also upset when I had called up there to inform them of the incident the woman I was speaking to (who claimed to be a manager) couldn’t even tell me how they cleaned their ovens. She seemed mildly concerned about the wire. I wasn’t looking for a credit or anything just simply worried as I have heard horror stories from people swallowing these. I never complain or write bad reviews so this is hard for me - especially a locally owned restaurant who I’ve always loved. But I think using wire brushes at this point should go against health violations and really something all restaurants should be aware of. I hope that the woman I spoke to at least informed other management of the incident but it’s hard to tell.