Pizza is amazing!!! The man working was super friendly as well! Our food was done quick
I ordered a cheese pan pizza and I was very disappointed considering the price ($40 for one large pizza and nothing else). The crust was overcooked and there was no sauce on the pizza. I had to double check I didn't accidentally order a white pan pizza. Fortunately although I didn't ask for a side of sauce one was included but it was too small to really cover the whole pizza. Which is a shame because I actually liked the sauce and seasoning, when I could taste it.Next time I'll just stick with dominos.
Its easily one of the best pizzas I've ever had!!! I had the 3 meat fyi. Lol
I am a native New Yorker, and was so hoping that this pizza would be a great substitute since I live here in St. Joe. I ordered the meat pizza and it was meh. The flavor of the pizza was very good and so was the size in diameter. However, the crust was paper thin and the toppings were sparse, with nearly no cheese on it. I really was hoping to be blown away, I just wasn't. It also cost me $25 for one 18 inch pizza. We have Casey's here in town, and will continue to get my pizza from them instead. I can get 2 pizzas for the price of one and it's actually closer to NY pizza then Pizza Tascio.
Love their pizza! You can watch them make it - even adults like to watch the process. I always make it a point to stop in when I’m in St. Joseph.
Just ordered for the first time tonight. It was amazing! It's exactly what it says it is...New York pizza! Huge slices, wonderful crust, light sauce, heaps of toppings. I'll never order another "chain" pizza again!
Best pizza in town. Each bite is full of flavor. Worth every penny!!! Also in an amazing location.
Did I call in after they were closed on opening night? yes. Did they still offer me a pizza if I was ok with cheese? yes. Do I ever order cheese pizza? no. honestly, best pizza I've ever had, and I've eaten a lot of NY pizza.
We really like the different styles from here. Pizza Shoppe is still my favorite, but for to go this has been our go to place.
The white pizza with broccoli and sausage changed my life in the best way possible. I will definitely be back!