I loved it. We have ordered veg pizza and garlic cheese bread. It was freshly made and pizza was loaded with veggies. Bread was soft and full with cheese, you may not find so much of garlic but taste was good. People were very familiar out there. I love root bear :) ... My kid went there for school trip and he enjoyed too.
Photos
Menus
We arrived around 610pm on a Friday night, the place was extremely busy not just with patrons wanting to sit down and eat but their to go counter was non-stop. We unfortunately had to wait about 30-40 minutes as a group of 20 arrived right before us, however they kept us informed while we waited. Once we were seated the server immediately greeted us and took our drink orders. Once the drinks arrived we placed our dinner orders and within minutes our salads had arrived. Very tasty creamy italian dressing topping off a salad with lots of provel cheese a favorite of mine. Shortly after our dinners arrived which included a Stefaninas Special pizza! Let me tell you it was delicious. It was loaded with toppings with the right amount of sauce and cheese! Would highly recommend their pizza, even if you order it to go!
Love the new fresh look! Been two years since we've been inside and we really enjoyed ourselves! Angie was fantastic! It was overall a delicious meal with family couldn't ask for more!
This was an amazing place to eat. I had the baked Mostacciola. I had to bring half home.
Went about 5 on a Saturday. Was packed by the time we left. Before we went in I saw tons of carry outs happening. This place was recommended to us. We were in the area for a comedy show and wanted a non chain place to eat beforehand. Food was great! A small pizza was huge, salads can seriously be split between 2 (would like a small of half salad option) extremely generous portions. Pizza was fantastic and dough hand tossed. Cannalloni -was asked if she wanted white or red sauce -red but got a tomato cream sauce-which was perfectly paired but she thought it would be a marinara. Tour of Italy-again huge . Enough for 2 people and leftovers. Overall food was fantastic. Service left a little to be desired. We had a reservation and we were sat right away even tho 2 of our oarty had not arrived. We were acknowledged and drink order was quick. Apps came out fairly quick as well. Salads and entrees took almost 40 minutes and were brought back to back. And the server who brought the food didn't know what some of the dishes were (we had 2 that were similar so we had to eyeball them to see difference) one of meals came with rolls and we had to ask for the rolls. Drinks got messed up a bit with refills when our main server wasn't doing them. I felt there was enough staff around that food shouldn't have taken that long and other tables that seated after us were getting stuff before us so not sure what was happening there. Maybe our server was having an off night? Bottom line food was great and we would try again.
One of the best places for St. Louis style pizza this side of the River. I only eat St. Louis Style, so I'm picky. We like the appetizers too, and my wife really likes their margaritas. Staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is family-like.
Great food. Everything I have ever eating there has been awesome. They actually put lots of cheese on their pizza unlike Imos. Their only downfall is 50% of the time the order is incorrect. Even after repeated requests they still screw up the order. Good luck trying to get bread with your meal, or meatballs on the side. But It's great to have them in our community
It was delicious! We will certainly be back. I loved the white sauce. The prices were very reasonable for the amount of food.
Food was great hot and delicious. Our server was in training and did an amazing job. Manager was shadowing her to make sure everything was smooth and that alone was awesome. Most of the time they just throw them into the water and expect them to swim. Can't wait to come back
My wife and I recently threw a fundraising party/open house and reached out to Stefanina’s to cater for us. They were an absolute pleasure to work with in planning our menu. Once we decided on a menu their catering experience came to play as they made suggestions on how much food we needed to order. Everything was provided.....chafing dishes, plates, cutlery and paper goods. We were even able to schedule multiple delivery times so the food would be fresh and hot as guests came and went during the open house.Overall it was a great experience and our guests were impressed with the quality and variety of the food. I would highly recommend Stefanina’s for any catering needs you may have.