Look I don't normally post reviews over anything but my god this pizza was by far some of the best pizza you are ever going to have in Kansas City. I got 1 slice for like 6 dollars and it was soooo big (pause). There was a little grease that dripped off the pizza after folding it but for the size compared to the amount of grease was great... Very well balanced in flavor and overall fantastic. 10/10 5 Star would recommend to a friend.
The waitress that we had was on point! Very nice and kept our drinks full. The pizza.... DELICIOUS!! I honestly wasn't expecting a big pizza like that to taste that good. That was our first time going and we will definitely be back!!
Bartender was great! 1st time here. Tried pepperoni slice. Good stuff! Will be back.
I am on a quest to find thee best pizza in all of Kansas City, so far I've been to four places including Fat Sully's, and Fat Sully's is by far the best pizza I've had in KC. I was really impressed with the size of the slice, the dough, sauce and even the crust, all pleasing to the taste buds. I ordered a slice with sausage and bacon, the only reason why this is not a five star review, is because I am not fan of crumbled bacon, I prefer actual pieces of bacon. Along with my slice, the bartender suggested, Sully's fries with half mushroom gravy and half sausage gravy, this was SUCH an added bonus, so good. The total was $13 and change, not bad and I walked away with a smile on my face and a full tummy. The food, the atmosphere and the service was excellent, to bad Fat Sully's doesn't have live music, it'd be great to go with a bunch of friends, enjoy some live music and really good food.
They have a walk up window that sells the biggest slice of pizza I’ve ever seen. They even give you a to-go box or a plate and you can add whatever toppings you like.
I have to say the pizza I ordered from here lived up to its name NY style pizza. Ordered from Door Dash when pizza arrived it was hot and was cooked to perfection. The slices were very big wasn't over cooked so next time I'm in the KC area will definitely order from here again...
Very picky when it comes to pizza and finally found a place me and my bf both love!! We went twice in one week and we never eat out. The service was very fast the first time and the second time, even though we were waiting in the ice cream shop next door, the worker came and told us it’ll be a little longer because he was making fresh dough. We didn’t even feel like we were waiting long at all but appreciated the communication. AND THE PIZZA IS DELICIOUS!
Great food especially since I'm an old Jersey boy, but they are losing my respect because it of 3 visits I've had lousy service twice and the last one was literally the worst waiter I have ever had. Too many issues to list. I hope they can fix their staffing issues or I may stop going.
OMGOODNESS. IT WAS GREAT
FAT SULLY’s OMG is all I need to say about this place. YOU GOTTA HO CHECK THEM OUT. It’s a MUST. I would suggest making reservations ERALY because you will be waiting because they are JUST THAT GOOD.