Very disappointed. This visit my husband asked for steak cooked medium and was brought a nearly rare on a bloody plate. The waiter removed mashed potato bowl from the bloody plate placing it on the table and sent the steak to be cooked longer. It was quick to return but tasteless. My daughter ate a few bites of rattlesnake pasta, complained about the pasta and garlic bread being lukewarm and tasteless. We were given boxes for leftovers but didn't take anything home. No one wanted to eat it once let alone twice.
Service was eh and food wasn't much better. Everything we had was lukewarm starting with the tater keg appetizer. I had a bowl of potato soup which only had two pieces of potato and way too much pepper. My mother had the blackened salmon. She found a bone in the fish and her grilled vegetable side was undercooked. The asparagus was rock hard. She had a side order of the garlic toast and was disappointed in it. It had no flavor and was just buttered toast. None of the staff seemed to care, we were never asked if everything was okay with our meal or anything. Our waitress just brought the check 2 minutes after delivering entrées. It was a Friday night and we were drinking water. I guess that means usher out the non-drinkers as fast as you can to replace them with drinkers to bump up the tip money.
Outstanding!!!Went with the recommended Chicken Madelnia. Chicken lightly breaded.. over mash. Asparagus topped with Jack cheese..Then the mushroom sauce!Brilliant flavors. Perfect execution. Great plating.Highly recommend this joint. Service was top notch. Atmosphere on point.Nice beers on tap.Such an expansive menu EVERYONE can find good eats here.Wish I had more time to explore all the menu.
Food was pretty decent but service was total mess.Waited over an hour for a table, then waited for an hour for food after receiving a table. Manager was nice and apologized and all, but I was very disappointed after hearing such great things about the place.I'd possibly give then another try if I'm ever back in the area, I guess everyone has an off day/ night.
had a fantastic meal along with a mezcal margaritas and a key lime pie. Food was great and as good as it all was the service was better. Thank you for a great dining experience
Loved the food and drinks, would definitely stop again when in the area
Today's visit was great. We sat in the patio, and the weather was perfect. Our server was injured, but he was the best one that we have ever had here. The food was very good, and the tater kegs were a very tasty discovery ?
All I can say is WoW! From beginning to end everything was perfect. I hold restaurants in general to high standards if you can't tell. Server was very attentive. Place was clean, almost to clean. So I start searching for dirt. Restroom nope. Under the tables nope. Baseboards WTH nope. Ok it's clean. Food was perfectly cooked and delivered hot n fresh. The way it should be. I haven't seen a place like this for a while. Congratulations 54th Street. As far as I'm concerned this ranks #2 next to the pros at Ramsey steak house. Keep up the great work!
Great menu! Service is very good, too!
We went there on 2-8-22, we ordered the Chicken Protein bowl and it was not the best because the chicken was rubbery! I also ordered a medium rare steak and it came out extremely rare almost uncooked. We normally go there and never have an issues, I'll chalk it up as a fluke and still give 3/5 stars.