Pagliai's Pizza & Pasta(Cape Girardeau)

1129 Broadway St, Cape Girardeau - 63701
162 reviews
Pizza Italian
(573) 335-0366

Great pizza parlor that's been a staple of Cape for decades. With continued excellence in delivering a quality pie, friendly staff, and nostalgic atmosphere, it has staked it's claim as among one of the best pies in MO, and will weather any storm.

Ordered online, showed up 10 minutes early, and got it 5 minutes later. Guys behind the counter were totally chill. Pizza was delicious and piled high with toppings.

I was positively surprised to find that they could accommodate my dietary needs as a vegan, I ordered the baked veggie pasta and they even had vegan cheese. It was incredibly delectable. Salad bar also had some options. I was very pleased, would definitely visit again if I were in the area.

How have I never eaten here but grew up in Cape my entire life ?? ? Better late than never! ? Thank you, Matthew for the superb service !!! The food is BOMB.COM! I had a sandwich with ham & provolone & their yummy homemade red sauce and it was ? my mom ate a sandwich as well- I also will be back so soon to try the pizza but 10/10 recommend stopping in!! ??

Great little pizza and Italian place! Been around for decades!! They have pizza, pasta, garlic bread, toasted ravioli, a salad bar and more.

Delicious pizza, pasta and appetizers in a laid back atmosphere. All the staff, waiter/waitresses are all great, they definitely keep your glad full no matter what you're drinking. Nice selection of adult beverages as well!I'd highly recommend stopping in for a bite if you're in the area.

A really fantastic local pizza place with a long history in Cape. Excellent service and excellent food. We are big fans. Owner Eric is a wonderful man dedicated to his product and his customer.

I don't care How good your food is but if the service staffs is bad I wouldn't set feet there again. The staffs looked at me from head to toe as I opened the door and walked into the restaurant. Look with contemptuous eyes as  I have money to eat at This restaurant? I called to order and I would curbside pickup but I changed my mind and walked into the restaurant myself to pickup I don't want the staff to suffer It's cold outside and they been busyI wasn't prepared to eat so I wasn't wearing a Gucci dress to eat I don't put on full makeup. This is just a small town in Missouri, not Paris France or Rome Italy. You don't have to look at me with such disdainful eyes. When my meal was finished, they pointed at the pizza box and said, 'This is your meal.' They didn't say a word of Thank you to me. They turned their faces away and facial expression in different directions.If compared to restaurants that sell the same type of food as you, for example: Mingle wood, Dog wood , Rosati , Bella Italian and Olive garden The service of your staff can't compete with them. I'm not very impressed. Never again!!

Great place to eat. The employees are great and helped pick out what to eat because everything is so good.

Food was amazing!! Must try if you're in town.