This is an Oxford must if you visit! The pizza is made right in front of you and we got in and out in under 10 minutes. They have desserts made by Bremma’s sweet treats and they are amazing!! The banana pudding is the best I’ve had and from cupcakes to Bundt cakes to scones! They have everything you need to cure a sweet tooth. Make sure you stop by!!!
Lovely place, friendly staff, and amazing food! Definitely the best Pizza I've had yet!
This pizzeria is off the beaten path but is amazing. Reminds me of what the mall pizzeria was but on a larder scale. the young staff adds a but if chipperness to the place, and service is always with a smile. Families come in by the generations, which is lovely to see that many enjoying the place. Th smells are amazing, always clean. I always find myself going threw the line twice.
Pizza was quite delicious. I wish the toppings on the pizza was cooked more but I can see that the crust was already getting the burnt look on it. It's a little pricey. The atmosphere was nice
Pizza was good, but I'm all about that cheesecake! I live 4 hours from Oxford but I can see myself driving 4 hours for another piece of that turtle cheesecake!
Best pizza in Ox. If you have a chance to meet John you will hear in less than 5 minutes of conversation his passion for the quality of ingredients. They know pizza!
I get that it is a family business, and I support the fact that a family wants to do this, but the product is not consistent. Burned pizza, and sub par salad has been my experience. The family can be nice, but there have been times where I could hear a family discussion while I was eating. If I could describe this restaurant in short, it would be "unprofessional". I hope it gets better one day, but I don't think it will be any time soon. I am not even one to write reviews most times, but this restaurant disappointed me in terms of food, and how they conduct their practice.
I am hesitant to give a low review, as the people have always been a pleasure to talk to on the phone and deal with. I have eaten here probably 6-7 times, each time it was picked up by a friend or my husband. I want to like it so badly, but I just can't recommend it at the moment. My pizza has been nearly completely black on the bottom, sometimes even leaving ash on the paper underneath it. The salad was good, but anything that goes in the oven is a 50/50 on if it is burned or not. The first time I had it was a few months ago, and it amazing. I don't know if they have a new oven cook or if I was just lucky that time. I really want to love this place and I hope it gets better soon. (Tina stone is not my real name, I just want to keep myself safe on the internet. If your name is Tina stone, sorry lol)
The pizzas were ordered for pickup and were ready on time. The pizzas were quite delicious. My favorite was the summer lovin' pizza was delicious and refreshing! The cheese sticks with the mozzarella I would eat again. The other pizzas were delicious! We all split 4 pizzas and they were gone in less than 10 minutes!
I lived in Oxford for a year and a half, and I visited Fergndan's several times a month. I was a member of their loyalty program, which I would recommend to any Oxford resident. The pizza is fantastic, but what really stands out about this place is the warm, friendly staff. Whether you're placing a to-go order or a guest at an event, they go above and beyond to make sure you have a wonderful experience. I recommend the Barnyard pizza and the triple chocolate cheesecake. The Reese's dessert pizza is also great. Such a charming place that makes you feel right at home, whether you're an Oxford local or visitor!