NY Style pizza was excellent. Meatballs were average. Caprese salad was bright and fresh.
This is a solid top 5 NYC style pie! They have a dozen pies as slice options and also make full pies. We did the full cup & char pepperoni which was extremely greasy but spot on for what we ordered. The crust is perfect and the sauce and cheese was the correct amount and paired perfectly with the crust. I would have picked a less greasy option but was out voted. Only complaint in the dine in is the plates were the paper style which is fine but these were bottom of the barrel and with the grease from the pie soaked right through to the table. Will be back regularly for slices but for full pies will avoid the pepperoni due to the grease. Highly recommended!
I also learned about this place from Tiktok. My husband and I love NY style pizza so we decided to check it out! We have gotten it twice in 2 weeks despite it being almost an hour from where we live. We have tried the pizza and wings- wings are MASSIVE! (Well, so is the pizza ?)….absolutely delicious- highly recommend!
I got a slice of pepperoni/sausage and a slice of the “garbage” (think supreme plus jalapeño) pizzas. The portions are generous (I should have ordered 1 slice). My first bite impressed me as the flavors are all fresh and the garlic crust offered a nice crunch with a burst of flavor. I preferred the pepperoni/sausage to the “garbage” slice.The wait time is minimal as the pizzas are already made. They just need to heat up the slice. They offer whole 18” pizzas too. My guess is that they take longer to prepare as they are made to order.The venue is modern and inviting, offering an upbeat vibe. The outdoor patio seating will be inviting when the weather finally warms up.It’s a great pizza option whether you want to eat in or take out.
best pizza I've had. everyone I recommend to come here loves it. my friend drove 40 minutes just to eat here. the people working here are awesome too super friendly hard workers. love this place.
This is hands-down the best NY pizza in the cities. This will go up in my top 5 favorite pizza spots ever. Staff was super friendly, place was very clean and new and the quality of their food was fantastic. I will definitely be back and will be worth the 30 minute drive it will take me to do so. Bravo, team ElMar, you guys are killing it in the pizza game and I’m glad you’re in MN!
Pizza so good I drive to the office to get it. NY pizza in MN. Best food, best people. Do yourself a favor and give it a try, you won’t regret it.
A foodie account I follow on TikTok recommended this place, and it is well worth the drive.I like that you can order pizza by the slice or a whole pie. We tried slices of pepperoni, BBQ chicken and garbage and they were all delicious.We also ordered garlic cheese bread, which was good but hardly touched because the pizza slices were so large.If you crave a giant slice of NY style pizza, this place has you covered.
Excellent pizza !! Great staff !! Well worth the hour drive ! We will be back !!
The pizza itself is great. But, you cannot talk to anyone one the phone because they don’t provide a phone number. They sold out for the night at 7:00 on a Saturday! I didn’t find this out until I drove there and tried to place an order with a human. She was not particularly pleasant about it. Guess she want to be done for the day. The fact that they were sold old early is an indication that they are a popular pizza option. But in the end it’s pizza and not worth the lack of customer service. I will not return.