I finally won the lottery and it was well worth the wait. A perfect pie (pear-blackberry with an all butter crust) and the nicest customer service. It was a pleasure to wait in line. Everyone was so happy to be waiting for the best pie in the Twin Cities - maybe the world.
Breathtakingly good pie. Just had my first taste of blackberry pear. Truly outstanding.
I lucked out big time and got two of their Apple Cranberry Pecan Crumble pies for Thanksgiving. This was the best pie I have ever had. Like, life changing good. I'm not a huge pie person and these were just heaven.
Great pies if you happen to get lucky in their lottery. If you don't, they're still great but you're only chance is a slice when they are open for pickup. Always a new pie to try and simply the best signature crust I've found!
Everything I've had from Pie & Mighty has been amazing - don't sleep on the Hoosier Mama Sweet Cream. I look forward to their email every week to see the new flavors and enter the lottery.
I'm seriously in love. I'm a huge pie fan and Pie and Mighty has some of the best pie I've ever tasted. It was worth every bite and then some. Definitely get in their pie lottery or stop by for a slice of pie.
I love this place. They've created such a warm, welcoming, kind place filled with the best pie you've ever had. Move over grandma!
Excellent, fresh pies by the slice. Whether you are looking for a classic pie done to perfection or something inventive to excite your tastebuds, this locally owned shop will have you realising, "I didn't know pie could be this good."P.S. My mom loves their pies and requests them for special occassions. Who needs birthday cake?
This is the tastiest pie with the freshest ingredients and most delectable crust I have ever had in my life. I would wait in line any day to experience this taste of heaven. It is painstakingly made with love by women who take the time to share motivating thoughts with their community. I'll keep coming back here always, I love it that much.
Wow!! Such a lovely shop/staff and PHENOMENAL pie. Definitely lives up to the hype. We got slices of cherry and key lime pie, and a peach blueberry dandy pie. All three were among the best pie I've ever had!