Smelled delicious when we walked in. Clean, quaint, great personable service! The pizza was so good! Fresh and very tasty. We did a day trip from the cities to Mankato! Highly recommend this lovely place!!!
Fantastic local old school pizza and hot sandwich place with some neat history and "real man's" portion sizes.You can watch the food being made from your seat too!
Great people work here. Bread is good, but to my personal tastes, the sauce was not my deal, and the ingredients (I love sausage) was horrible! Not at all amazing as I was told it would be.
This was the best pizza we had in ages! We were there at lunchtime and ordered a large “Works” pizza. We loved the thin crust, tasty sauce, and abundant ingredients. We ate our fill, yet ate only half; we enjoyed the remaining for our next day’s meal! We don’t get to Mankato often, but can’t wait for our next visit. By the way, our friendly waitress shared that their name is pronounced “Polly Eyes.”
My husband and myself both attended MSU in 1981 and 1982. We haven't had Pagliaia since. We came back today and it is EXACTLY as we remember!!!!! What an awesome experience! Thank you for your continuance of excellence!!!
great Pizza! Great service!
Best of all around and it has a very long history at being the best family friendly seating with outstanding service. Your pizza will never taste any better than a Pagliai's
We had to hunt for a parking spot, but it was worthwhile. The interior is not fancy, but service was quick, the beer was cold and the pizza was FANTASTIC.
I hate to complain but I ordered paglias pizza at 6:45. It was supposed to take up to an hour and a half for the delivery. We are still waiting, even though it has been out for delivery for more than 30 minutes.Last time we did Paglias they made the wrong pizza. Is it only me who has an issue here. Now I have paid 26 dollars for a really cold pizza? If it comes, that is.Does this happen to anyone else?
VERY Disappointed! Called at 6:15pm to order a pizza and understood it would take 1.25 hours. At 7:45pm called to see where our order was & was told it went out the door 30 seconds. It took 2.45 hours to get our pizza. When it arrived it came cold and not even cut. I will never order here again!