He atmosphere is really nice but I thought my dinner was ok. I had pork chops and my husband had ribeye. He liked his but I thought mine was mediocre. The blueberry cheesecake wasn’t that good. The drinks were really good and the staff was really friendly but I probably won’t go back.
Definitely a restaurant to check out. Very comfortable feeling just sitting here.Old City Hall restaurantIn downtown Bay City, MichiganGreat staff. Very friendly. Plenty of staff. The bartenders, Mandy and Dani were very attentive and courteous but not over friendly. The company general manager was here and working as hard as all the staff. I'm impressed. I enjoyed the delicious bibimbap. It was mild and not overly spicy. The calamaris was cooked perfectly. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting. The live music is calm, relaxing and adds to the overall atmosphere. Check my pics to see menu. I absolutely recommend this great establishment/restaurant. A must visit whether you're traveling north or south, east or west in Michigan. Definitely family friendly. My compliments to executive chef Ryan Cole-Clark.Oldcityhallrestaurant.comTo order online
Thank you to Collin for being an amazing server and making our anniversary dinner special. He went above and beyond to make the night a great one. The food and service was wonderful. If you’re looking for a good night out come here and ask for Collin!!!
Went out for dinner with a couple of my friends the other day. We wanted to try something new and drove to Bay City from Midland. We were waited on by Taylor R. and her service was just excellent! Worth the drive, time and money! Food was great and cooked to perfection. Would and have recommended for anyone in the Tri-Cities.
I was in town visiting, and I stopped in to have a few drinks and food with my friends. My server, Taylor, was amazing. Her energy was so happy and welcoming. She gave recommendations and they did not disappoint. It’s hard to find nice servers now a days. I will be coming back soon!
My husband and I came in a few days ago and had a wonderful experience! Our dinner was spectacular and our server was so attentive and sweet! Madisyn was awesome!! Thank you Old City, we will be coming back!
Dinner on a Saturday night for my birthday. Not sure if they were understaffed or if everyone was busy setting up for the private party in the other room... but there was no hostess at the station. Multiple people walked past us and ignored us, until the bartender acknowledged our existence. We were seated and then waited longer than we should have for a Waitress.The bartender eventually came over to our table, and apologized, stating "we don't usually wait on tables, but apparently we are tonight..."She returned with our drinks and asked if we were ready to order.That's when we were given a plastic holder and welearned you have to scan a qr code to get the menu, which isn't really a menu. It takes you to a take out order screen, that is miserable to navigate.Focaccia with dip was good.Prime rib sandwich was inedible. It was so salty I could barely eat half the sandwich. Fries were barely warm.Mushroom chicken dish wife ordered had undercooked/a gob of noodles plopped on a plate, with a slice of banquet style chicken breast, and what appeared a can of Campbell's mushroom soup poured on it.Let's be honest here, this is a fine dining establishment, but this food and service were not.2 stars because the bartender tried...
Over on this side of the state for the weekend and heard great things about this place. Lived up to the reputation! Food and service were really spot on. Had kids with us and very family friendly. Everyone in our group very satisfied!
My server Emilie was attentive and friendly. She was on-top of refills and picking up the empty plates. Best server I have ever had I will be coming back forever because Emilie made this experience so wonderful.
Visited 12/30/21What a great experience! The waitress Madison was awesome, attentive and has a great memory.The place was clean (except for bathroom door)The food was good, took a while but it was worth the wait.The raspberry donut cheesecake is a must try! The lemon cream cake was also amazing!A must visit.