Fun rotating selection of pies, teacakes, scones, cookies, and more! I'm not typically a fruit-pastry person, but every flavor of tea cake I've tried has been an absolute home run.
Simply the very best pies in the world.. nothing makes my day more that when my wife brings home a Petsi Pie. Our favorite is the cherry pie..
Stopped in today and was really excited to try a pastry. The cherry crumb bar was terrible! Was wet and mushy. Felt so stale and poorly made. Also there was a bad smell inside. Worker was kind, but I will it be returning
Probably delicious, but if you order for pickup just be aware that you will not receive any type of reminder communication or notification, even when the pie won't be ready for almost two weeks from the time you ordered. Be sure to put the pickup on your calendar.
As others have noted the pies here are delicious! A great variety of flavors and they have been consistently high quality. Pecan and apple are especially good.However, I’ve been really let down by their others pastries. On several occasions I’ve tried muffins, scones, biscuits, and other items and every time they’ve been dense, gummy, and bland. At first I wrote this off as a fluke and kept giving them the benefit of the doubt, but even though I keep trying they just aren’t very good. Bit of a shame.Better stick to the pies. They won’t let you down!
LOVE Petsi Pies! Cute community store, but most importantly lovely pies. High quality, make for a great gift. Favorites include brown butter pecan, mixed berry & their seasonal key lime!
Got a blueberry pie to go. It was very good. Tons of mini blueberries, not overly sweet, and a nice crust.
Great pastries, pies and anything sweet. My go-to items are the teacakes, cinnamon rolls, cookies, carrot cake and apple pie!
My partner and I ordered their cutie pies and some regular size pies for our wedding two weeks ago. The pies were a big hit with our guests, and the team at Petsi was easy to work with!
My partner and I ordered their cutie pies and some regular size pies for our wedding two weeks ago. The pies were a big hit with our guests, and the team at Petsi was easy to work with!