Brooklyn New York Pizza

251 W Central St, Natick - 01760
96 reviews
Pizza
(508) 655-5355

Im not one to take to the internet , but this place was just too good not to give credit too . Literally the best pizza I’ve ever had . I would’ve added a picture , but I feel like I blinked and the box was empty . My very picky brothers were fighting over the last slice . I’ve lived in the next town over my whole 25 years of life and I had never heard of this place until I actually chose it by accident on Grubhub , and I have never been so pleasantly surprised by a meal I got delivered . You really can’t beat the prices either . The delivery was SUPER quick . From the time I ordered to pizza in my hand was probably about 30 minutes , even with the distance . I won’t be ordering from anywhere else anytime soon ! You guys are amazing !

Our new favorite place to get take out!! We have tried pizza, sandwiches and dinner entrees, all were great.

I saw them making the food and they are not wearing gloves and I've been in the bathroom I don't think they even wash their hands either

Ordered large thin crust with eggplant. I opened the box at counter in front of owner and it was clearly thick crust with barely visible slices of eggplant. So I guess the eggplant and not the crust is thin! Also, NOT Brooklyn, NY style pizza which is dripping with olive oil and ample sauce. Rather, than argue I paid and left!

Ordered large thin crust with eggplant. I opened the box at counter in front of owner and it was clearly thick crust with barely visible slices of eggplant. So I guess the eggplant and not the crust is thin! Also, NOT Brooklyn, NY style pizza which is dripping with olive oil and ample sauce. Rather, than argue I paid and left!

I used to LOVE getting the Astoria St Sandwich, and I'd always add grilled chicken to it for extra protein. The most recent takeout order I requested this, but upon getting home realized they left the chicken out even after I specified that twice. I live nearby so I called and asked if they could amend this, so they implied they'd make me a new one with what I'd asked for. I arrive 10 minutes later after clarifying again that I just needed the grilled chicken on it, and they hand me a box with a single piece of FRIED chicken, no new sandwich. At this point my original sandwich was getting soggy and I did not want that much fried food, so I just left feeling disappointed.

Not amazing, but best pizza I've found in the area. True to name, would be a respectable showing in the New york metro area.

Might be good pizza, I don't know. But don't lie about when you close on Google Maps! They say they close at 10pm, but I showed up at 9pm on a Thursday night and they were very much closed!

This place is the most amazing place in the area! The food NEVER DISAPPOINTS! Restaurant is clean, staff is friendly, food is always cooked fresh and served hot!! I’ve come here quite a few times and always try something new, I’ve never been disappointed! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!

Moved to Natick Village recently, first time getting Pizza here and i will probably try the other spots that are closed on Sundays before returning here. Pizza is very dry (The Amsterdam), everything was overcooked, lots of burnt crust, etc.The people were very nice though!