AWFUL!!!Who the heck put a cold sub with mayo on the bottom of a bag with hot foods. The sub is now soggy and gross! The cheeseburger was so greasy that the fries in the box turned to mush. Such a waste of $$$$$ all sitting in the trash can now!!!!!
An old friend from Marlborough had an unexpected death in her family, and with my now living in Michigan, meant it would be difficult for me to get good, plentiful food to her house for friends and relatives. I called The Plum Tomato and they delivered a fantastic selection of platters that evening. The word I got back was glowing. They delivered right on time and the food was delicious.
Ordered chicken parm sandwich here. Great food, great service
Amazing fresh food! Absolutely love this place! Very friendly service too!
Good local place for pizza. I was surprised at how quickly the food was made. Mozzarella sticks weren’t overly fried and were just heavy enough. Pizza has a thin crust, but could have used a little more sauce. Good option on the east side of Marlborough
My 1st and last time ordering. Order instructions not followed, food was cold, pizza crust was like eating cardboard. I literally threw an entire large pizza less 1/2 slice in the trash.Sub par quality, sub par ingredients, sub par taste. Over priced.
10/10I didn’t receive exactly what I ordered however they immediately fixed it, delivered it and it was perfect and hot!
Rachael at the front was so friendly and knowledgeable about menu!
The pizza here is easily the best in Marlboro (and I would argue the best in the 'boros). Believe me, I have tried pretty much every pizza place in the surrounding area. Every time I eat a non-Plum Tomato pizza I'm left with the same feeling of "dang, I wish I just had gotten Plum Tomato". Their dough is perfect, it has the right amount of chew, crunch, and bready flavor. The toppings are all high quality and they do not skimp with the quantity of what goes on the pizza. Their specialty pizzas are all super tasty, creative, AND fairly priced (very inexpensive for what you get!). It reheats well and is also good cold the next few days. Seriously, do NOT bother with pizza for anywhere else. Beyond the pizza, the staff is always welcoming and the estimated wait times for pick up and delivery are spot on. Don't settle for pizza from anywhere else around here, just get Plum Tomato.
Horrible!! Is the Plum Tomato under new ownership? I used to love their food, but for the second time I am beyond disappointed. Tonight I ordered a chipotle chicken sandwich - it tasted nothing like chipotle at all and the chicken was dry. My sweet potato fries were so soggy they weren't edible. And my cheesy garlic bread was just a bunch of pieces of cheese slathered sub roll that looked like they were just dumped in the box - or tossed around before delivery. It was a box of mess.I won't be ordering from PT again, that's for sure!