I ordered a large steak and cheese with side order of small fries. Not until my order was ready was I told cash only. Having no cash I offered to leave my credit card with them and I would come back later with cash to retrieve it. The owner said no need, just take your order and you can pay us next time you come in. How many restaurants would do that? My sandwich was the best tasting steak and cheese I had ever had. A few days later I went back and ordered the same meal. When it was time to pay I explained to the cashier that I owed him double because of my previous order. The cashier thanked me for my honesty and told me that my unpaid for order was on the house. I told him that I wanted to pay, but he refused to let me. Needless to say, I am a loyal customer for life. Great tasting food, very reasonable prices and over the top friendly service. What more could you ask for?
How can a business run like this I’ve tried to order four separate times on four separate days to have the phone ring and ring with no answer ever. I don’t leave a lot of reviews especially negative ones, but I’m sorry I’ve never dealt with a place that doesn’t answer their phones. I’m not trying to order at peak hours either it’s 11 am on a Saturday and this is the fourth time this has happened would love to actually try their pizza if they would answer the phone unless there is secret phone number google is hiding or something
Love Nickeys!! Best pizza around, always make it just the way I like it!!!!
Quite possibly Lynn’s best pizza! 60 years of history here
Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had and great prices
Definitely a 5+ star rating! Nicky and staff very friendly and welcoming! Not only great food but great value for your money.Best steak & cheese, meatball, chicken parm, all sooo good, hard to choose! Unique great, tasting pizza as well; not to mention their steak fries. It is our local go to place? with a smile!!!We have never been disappointed.Thank you, Nicky for your good work ethics to serve your community!?
Been going to Nicky's for over 35 yrs. Their pizza is awesome! Best pepperoni pizza on the planet! The subs are plentiful and rolls are so fresh. Veal parm, steak & cheese, Italian, all soo good. Best steak fries around. Nicky and his family are so nice! What else can I say? Old school simple menu, great prices, amazing food, great hard working family. One of the gems in the City.
This place is a joke I went to pick up my pizza then one of the guys he was making a pizza help me with my order his hands full of flour from the Pizza dub no gloves he took my money and give me my change and then he went back to continue making the pizza he was making he didn't watch his hands and no gloves now I wonder how many other things he does with his bare hands touching things here and there and making pizza and subs and every other team in that kitchen without watching he's hands or not wearing gloves
Visiting from Michigan and quickly picked a pizza place. All I can say is FABULOUS!! I haven’t had pizza this good in a very long time!! You won’t be sorry. YUM YUM
Authentic pizzeria style pizza. So good!!