If you love pie a la mode get the pie milkshake! It's the best! I hope they get a drive through someday.
As Salisbury University Alumni and starch believers that pie trumps cake every time, choosing Ugly Pie as our wedding dessert caterer was a no brainer. The pies were DELICIOUS - may I recommend the chocolate chip cookie?? We did mini pies, which I think was a great choice. I saw a lot of couples with like 2-3 different flavors and each sharing. We also got a large blueberry cheesecake pie to do for our "cake" cutting, and it was delicious.Ugly Pie was also great to work with, incredibly flexible and helpful when my overwhelmed bride brain gave them the wrong date (whoops) and delivered our dessert with ease.Please get Ugly Pie for your next event!!! It is so worth it!
I have bought several pies in the past for holiday dinners but truly had never tasted most of them. Bought 3 for Easter dinner and my family and guests lost their minds!! (Me too!) They were drop dead amazing!!! Many guests didn’t have room for dessert and so they took a piece home. I had phone calls for the next 3days from guests that said the pies were the best they have ever had! I don’t usually keep deserts at home as I have little will power but I’ve decided now to at least buy 1 pie every month. I hope & pray that heaven is my next step in this journey of life but I also know that these pies make me feel 1step closer. Heavenly, and amazing!
I love this gem. Great even for those that are lactose intolerant. I can order quite the selection without dairy in it. You can ask for a menu and what things can be made without dairy, they have alternatives. So much is so delicious, my husband and brother enjoy coming with me to get some goodies.
Delicious pies- lots of choices and kind smiling people!
****Updated below initial post****Horrible customer service. “Shop Manager” Sandy needs retraining. I will be calling to speak with an owner. You have lost future business and I will not be referring anyone to your store.Leaving signs in the display case advertising a product. They ring me up and I paid. Turns out they do not have any of the advertised product. I ask for a punch on the card as a type of reimbursement for the mistake. I was very excited for what I already paid for and then get told they don’t have it. Mistakes were made, nothing was done to correct it. Shop Manager gives me attitude after I complain. Unfortunate, but buyer beware.Update (1 hour ish after initial post). I messaged the Facebook page directly and I got an immediate response from one of the owners. I let her know the situation and she was great at de-escalating the situation: she validated my feelings and offered me fair compensation for the situation. In addition, she even informed me that she decided to put a new policy in place that a customer will not be rung up until all purchased product is boxed and ready.The products they sell are delicious and because of the great customer service provided by the owner I will continue to my future business.
Small but large presence!!! All the pies are fresh with an always changing menu. Sweet, savory, quiche all of their choices have a lasting impression. Always come early because they sell out quick. Coffee and sitting area with books for the littlest of fans. Never disappoints.
Me and my mom ordered the Christmas bundle and let me tell you the chocolate peppermint it’s beyond out of this world delicious, I love everything about ugly pie!
Dear Ugly Pie,
I'm now excited to bring something to any get together I have. The Ugly Pie has phenomenal options and the kindest staff. I always feel welcome. Everything is AMAZING. When frie do come to visit, it's now one of the go-to spots to bring them to. Go there now and eat as much as you can. You'll be happy.