Cafe Italia Restaurant & Pizzeria

935 Pennsylvania Ave, Hagerstown - 21742
161 reviews
Pizza Italian
(240) 420-6677

We feel bad for the restaurant. We come in and spend $35 more worth of food and they find it necessary to charge for a couple extra pieces of bread not only that they charge 4% processing fee to use the credit card system. We've been going there for years the food is always excellent but they must not be doing well to start nickel and diming the customer. Thinking that they can charge extra for a couple pieces of bread is only flattering themselves and insulting the customer.. the bread is not that good.

It was full of a local Italian charm. It had Italian music playing at a perfect level. It was not too large, very cozy and intimate. Only one waitress for floor but she was very personable and relaxed and took good care of everyone. Loved the pizza, I am a crust girl so two thumbs up there. My hubby got a sub and the freshly baked on site roll was amazing. We also had the shrimp basket which came with fries and it was crunchy and well seasoned. It was an overall enjoyable experience and will return. ??

First time there. Food was amazing. Great experience. Will definitely be going back!

Always great service and fabulous food! Been going here for almost two decades. Delicious!

The food(seafood pasta)overall was pretty good. I did have a problem with the gentleman working the front, he had a really bad habit of wiping his nose with his hand. He seen that I saw and he washed his hands. Most people would have went on with their duties without washing. Still and all around good place to order

This is our favorite delivery pizza place! The Meat Lover’s Pizza was perfectly made all the way down to the delicious crust. Our entire family gave it a thumbs up!

Love it! But would go more often & eat entrees if they had gluten free pasta. Tempted to ask if they would like me to bring my own pasta!?

We ordered 3 Lg pizzas and quoted a price. When I picked them up the price was a few dollars more. Didn't pay any attention added a few dollars more for a tip and left. Reviewed the bill later and found a $2.46 service charge added. This is a charge i will never pay again because I will never go back. No way to do business.

Best and wonderful place to get the greatest food in the world see MIKE I HAD CHICKEN PARMIGIANA AND GARLIC BREAD SALAD AND Tiramisu THANK YOU SO SO MUCH MIKE FOR EVERYTHING FOR MY BIRTHDAY

Ordered a calzone tonight and the dough was freaking amazing! We greatly enjoyed the dipping sauce as well. It was more like a vodka sauce than pasta sauce or marinara. Super delightful! Highly recommend! We've also had their subs in the past and the homemade sub rolls were out of this world. I'm pretty positive that Cafe Italia wins for best bread/dough!!! Haven't had their breadsticks but I'm guessing those are awesome too.