5 Stars is an understatement for the service me and my family received today. First, my younger brother came and was looking for cake pops. My mom bought six for us and my grandmother. The lady that worked there gave him a free one. Additionally, My mom inquired about my graduation (in Spring 2023 Lord God willing) and I told her I’ll be a HS Senior in the Fall (Lord God willing as well) which is why we inquired. She offered me a free cake pop! Finally, my dad was standing in the rain and she gave him a free cake pop too. Not to mention the stellar kindness and smile she displayed behind her mask! Thank you.
Lots of yummy options here to soother any sweet-tooth craving you might be having. Lots of great choices!! We tried Raspberry Lemon, chocolate Ganache, peanut butter brownie, snickerdoodle, and Red Velvet! Every flavor is delicious and the service was very kind! Highly recommend this delectable spot! ?
The cupcakes look amazing!Had a chocolate ganache and a vanilla cake pop.The girl working was really friendly and answered all our Qs patiently.
Customer service is not the greatest. Cupcakes are not good. I tried three different flavors (funfetti, carrot, coconut) and a sugar cookie. Funfetti tasted just like eggs, coconut was a little sour, and carrot was dry. The cookie was salty. However, my husband said it was ok. But the presentation of the treats is adorable.
The flavoring is good, especially the snickerdoodle cupcake. Unfortunately, the cake part on all of the cupcakes was SUPER dry! Like really dry, they didn’t pass the kid approved test?.
Their cupcakes are pretty good. I’m just frustrated that I sent an email, to find out if it is possible to place an order for my daughter’s birthday and it’s been a hassle to get a response.
Delicious cupcakes, all of the flavors are a must try. If you ever had Georgetown Cupcakes this compares and some of the flavors are better. A must try
Wow! I heated from a friend that this place was better than Georgetown Cupcakes… and I after taking a few of their cupcakes, I have to agree! Lilly Magilly’s cupcakes are better than Georgetown Cupcakes, Baked n Wired, and Sprinkles. This is a highly recommended! The cupcakes just melts in your mouth!
Worth the read!!! I really do not like writing negative reviews unless necessary and in this case it is very necessary. This cupcake shop is very nice looking and we have bought cupcakes from them for about a year now. Some flavors are meh and typical, while others are fantastic! If you want to pick up cupcakes or holiday sweets (like we have in the past) I truly believe they have some great options and flavors.Now, here is where my 1 star comes into play. I requested custom cakes, cookies and cupcakes for an event I was having. When I walked into the shop to initially make my first request about my custom order, the employee gave me a weird look and odd response. Almost like I was an inconvenience. I shook it off thinking I was overthinking it. I proceed to talk to the owner and she reassured me she could easily do it and we had plenty of time. Instead of taking my official order. She hands me her card, takes my information and says she will contact me and also says I can contact her. I oblige and contact her with an email. 6 days goes by, no response. I email the second email and another 4 days goes by no response. I call and they answer and re-take my information down and say "we will call you right back" and still NO RESPONSE. I call one last time and they "reassure me" again and still no response. 4 times. FOUR TIMES. STILL TO THIS DAY NO RESPONSE.Now, I don't know what is hard about Winnie The Pooh, a follow up in email or calls (I have receipts) or just having good customer service. I have seen them open their binder of custom orders in front of me, but why was mine neglected and not taken seriously? Was it their unprofessionalism? Lack of ability to do my theme? Lack of design skills? The color of my skin? All the above? Not sure. But they will no longer receive my business. I am glad they fell through because now I have one of the top rated designers completing my order who is highly rated by multiple sites and businesses in this area. I am disappointed because I thought this place would be perfect considering how much we buy from them but not any more. I do not recommend this place especially for custom orders. Also never felt so disregarded by a business in my life.
This place has the freshest cupcakes you'll ever try. I've gone to another place called GW cupcakes and its not nearly as good as Lilly's. I recommend their snicker doodle and chocolate ganache. I won't eat it everyday but once in awhile good to treat yourself to an outstanding pastry. They've been around a long time and i hope they stay in business, so try it out today! :)