Mayneee I still think about this cake from time to time. I ordered this for my Nikkah (Islamic wedding) cake, told them how what I wanted it, brought the flowers in the day before pick up and it was perfect. Like I’m not even exaggerating rn this was the best cake I’ve had in my life (and I’m not even fond of cake like that). Plus, I think they said it would feed around 30 people but we had plenty left over after having a 30+ home wedding. One layer was lemon filling and the other raspberry— I might have to reorder this for an anniversary or two LOL I miss it that much. Thank you guys for making me the nikkah cake I didn’t even know I wanted ?. Salaam
My first and last Triple Berry Pie delivery from Two Cats Bakery:( Picking up a fresh pie must be the only way to go because the one I was delivered was awful! The crust was way too thick, dry, almost rock-like, even after heating. You can lift the whole pie out of the pan with two fingers to see the way-overcooked bottom. I'm glad I auditioned it a week before the birthday party.
LOCATED NEAR MARGINAL WAY ON ELM STREET THE TWO FAT CATS IS AN EXTRAORDINARY BAKERY SERVING PIES AND OTHER DELIGHTFUL DESSERTS.
What can I say…. The best pies I’ve ever had in my wntire life by a mile. Finally a pie shop that doesn’t drown their ingredients in Cinnamon… my personal favorites are the rasberry pies and apple pies. They only pick fruits that are in season and the crust is just delicious. It’s also not overly sweet which is a problem for most pies. They do run out before closing so don’t expect a large choice if you show up at the end of the day but they are worth showing up early for. I think we’re up to at least 15 pies this year!
Fresh, clean and busy as bees. They got pie! I did have the local eggnog
Pastries have little sweetness. Biscuits were gummy not flakey. A huge disappointment.
I walked here for a snack not know what to expect and found awesome pie. The blueberry pie was flavorful with perfect crust. They sell whole pies and it seems like they pick a few flavors to sell by the slice. They also had cookies and other baked goods available. Fair prices. A little walk off the main drag but worth it.
Only grabbed a cup of coffee, but the baked goods looked phenomenal. I'll try something next visit. ?
Made a special point of looking for this place after hearing so much about it. I was very disappointed with the blueberry pie and found the chocolate whoopie pie ok. The BB pie dough was soggy (uncooked?) and filling lacking blueberries. The whoopie pie was small, the chocolate cake part was like any cake would be, filling was very creamy and not over sweet. I would not make a special point to return. Spoke with three different employees and not one asked how the pies were.
Berry pies are quite good. Are they worth the price? Questionable. I frankly don’t think the hype is deserved but its good sweets for a small city