Reginelli's Pizzeria

684 Jefferson Hwy, Baton Rouge - 70806
169 reviews
Pizza Italian
(225) 231-1313

Restaurant was clean. Food quality was great. This place has been around for years and the food has so far been consistent. The pizza isn’t greasy nor is it doughy. The combination of toppings pairs to make a delicious pizza. Even eating the pizza the next day was good and I hate day old pizza. Our waiter was attentive and hospitable to my guest who asked for an extra side of marinara and drinks a lot. The tea is freshly brewed with unsweetened and sweetened tea choices. This is the pizza I pictured the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles ordering- flavor and all. Im talking about the OG TMNT.

As a way to mediate between high gas prices I guess they no longer deliver during weekdays before 5pm which when I like to order my food. If that's true as I was just told that is an unfortunate sign. You will just continue to lose business. Good luck guys I used to love it when the food matched the service. A pizza parlor that doesn't deliver during lunch....not a great sign since cheese only lasts a week.

The Ceasars salad was great and that's where it ends. My calazone was incorrect and appeared overdone(burnt). I was compensated with another calazone that was correct but it too was in the oven to long .

Today we visited the Jefferson Highway location and overall the pizza was good. However, we ordered the king cake mardi gras bread pudding and it was undone, watery, and the cream was melted all over the top. Before we go to this moment, we asked the waitress if we could change the king cake bread pudding to the chocolate cake. we realized that we did not want to try the bread pudding because we would rather get our usual chocolate cake. We asked the waitress if we could change our order to chocolate cake instead of bread pudding and they replied "no, we already cooked it". We were not asking for a free chocolate cake, we just wanted to change our desert. When the bread pudding came out we could not eat, it was runny and uncooked looking. Not only did we have to endure an order we did not like, the manager made us feel extremely uncomfortable. I really hate that this happened today because we have been there a lot, but this was the worst experience today.

Been only a couple of times, but each time it was a fantastic experience. No huge wait to be seated and the staff is extremely friendly. No reason not to go back. They do carry out and sit in both with the same friendly attitude. They need to be in your rotation so that you can get away from the hum-drum of the classic chain pizza.

We are from Chicago and have particular pizza preferences (the only reason we didn't give 5/5 stars). This is absolutely the best we have had in the area.

Overall, the texture of the pizza was perfect. It had just the right amount of crunch on the crust. There was this unexpected sweetness to the dough that just didn’t do it for me. The pepperoni was over done. It wasn’t a bad pizza, it just wasn’t the best pizza.

That was the best pizza of my life. The crust, the marinara, the cheese, and everything else was so tasty and fresh. The tiramisu was great as well.Thank you guys for such a great service.

It's a little spendy but definitely worth it. One of the better pizza places in town. The Detroit style is amazing!

A friend of ours recommended this restaurant. We went for the 1st time last week and had the most wonderful dinner. I got a small pizza and my husband got a muffalatto. The pizza was exceptional!! And he said he loved the sandwich and it tasted like a New Orleans muffalatto. We will go again.