J. Bella's Pizzeria

2406 New Holt Rd, Paducah - 42001
125 reviews
Pizza Italian Salad
(270) 554-1123

Loved it. The food was great. Served faster than expected and the people were extremely friendly. Next time we are in Paducah we will be eating there again. The Price range per person I selected was because we ordered a large for 3 people. Chicken strip appetizers with ranch and honey mustard sauce. So delicious. Chicken was freshly cooked and super hot when served. Big Thanks to the staff there that made us feel welcome being from out of town visiting our daughter. Sorry I can't remember their names. Big guy with a beard (who I think owned the place) and a pretty young blonde who served us. Great folks. Thanks again.

Nice pizza shoppe with a real hometown vibe. The customer service was fantastic, the pizza was amazing.Our order came exactly as requested. Piping hot and big as a wheel on my car (ok, maybe a slight exaggeration but it was BIG). For reference we dis order the largest size they make.I love a thin crispy crust and they knocked it outta the park!If you haven't tried them yet, you are missing out.

The best pizza! The sauce and the crust the best! And they are super nice!

Quick, affordable, ingredients were quality and in a good amount. Crust only comes in thin and is very crispy. Atmosphere was pleasant and owner was personable and helpful. Would go again.

Pizza is absolutely delicious and the service is always awesome! Perfect family restaurant!

Great pizza and I love their Italian beef calzone.

Easily the best pizza in Paducah and it was when Jeff had it in Metropolis. I have seen these guys personally make every pizza and bread item they have from scratch. Fresh ingredients and plenty of toppings on all of the pizzas. Thin crust is honestly the way to go with pizza since you don't feel miserable and bloated after.

Was going to get a small Kitchen Sink pizza. Ordered a 10" for myself and a side of spaghetti.No pasta in the house and no 10" pizzas. Only 16 and 20" pizzas. This is my first time there. Least to say that I was a bit disappointed. I had planned this for a couple of days. Now I don't know if it is worth another try or not. I'm alone and either of those other sizes would have been far to much for one person.

I called for a pizza while traveling from Benton to Paducah to see a movie at a friend's houseSettled on a pizza called the kitchen sink. It was delicious. The leftover pizza was even better the next morning!

called for a pizza while traveling from Benton to Paducah to watch a movie at a friend's house