Old Chicago

1924 Pavillon Way, Lexington - 40509
253 reviews
Pizza Sports Bar American
(859) 977-4640

At 15 minutes with no drink order, I went to the server stand. Finally got drinks at 30 min mark. They were out of my first draft beer request. The restaurant was at about 30% capacity and there appeared to be plenty of staff wandering around. Our server appeared to be stoned, but the copious amount of cologne would have covered up any smell. No plates, no silverware, pizza came out but they forgot our salads. When we finally got our food, it was ok. 3 star pizza and 1 star service.

So about 2 years ago I had a really bad experience and never went back. Went this past Friday, and had an experience to make up for my bad one, they managed to fit a table of 14 at 10p.m, had a great server. Food was also delicious.

Very good food and even though I came in close to closing they were still very friendly and outgoing

Food was pretty good. They have a solid pizza, but the service was phenomenal. I think my waiter was named Matt, but he looked after the table well and was very polite to my girlfriend and I. Top notch

we had the worst service ever tonight. the waitress was talking about the bar tender not doing their job,but yet she didn't enter in parts of our meal. my son's meal was 39 minutes after we got our. I didn't eat when he didn't have his meal. we will never be back.

Hands down best deep dish pizza I’ve ever had! Our door dash driver was excellent! I wish we had one back in Michigan. I will definitely order again!

Great food and service!Love it that I can have pizza here and it not crash my diet, since they offer cauliflower crust.When I stopped by they had old southern rock playing. Great atmosphere!

This trip wasn’t the best food or experience, (I’m sure COVID related) but usually I would rate a 5 star. This is our 1st option and favorite place to go when we go to Lexington. The Italian Nachos are to die for and you get a large amount. The Chicago crust is awesome! Definitely will return and still recommend!

First time here, pizza was good, nothing to get excited about, at least for my taste. They had just restarted buffet, but did not know it or was told about it till after we ate. Buffet would have been cheaper and could of sampled more items.

Burger was great, pizza was extremely overcooked/burnt. Probably won't do again, unless for burgers. Which is a shame...pizza used to be fantastic at the one in OKC. Oh well...same story, different business I guess.