Pizza tastes like any other pizza, I was expecting something New York style. The only thing that seemed New York style was the bigger slices and the bigger prices. Decent atmosphere, but small, overpriced and the bartender wasn't one to talk much to anyone, not what I expect from a bartender. I probably won't go back at all, especially not for the pizza!
Amazing pizza, amazing staff, nice vibes. Not much space to sit downstairs for groups but they have space upstairs. Can’t recommend this place enough.
THE MEATBALLS ARE DELICIOUS! First ate here during NKY Pride 2021, and finally made it back today for lunch. The staff made sure all our needs were taken care of. My dear friend ordered a margarita pizza without realizing it didn’t have marinara sauce, and they brought her a slice of delicious cheese pizza. I had a side of meatballs that were fabulous, and the bartender created a delicious mocktail with nothing to go on beside my “not too sweet”. I will definitely return.
great NY style pizza and a cute little whisky bar upstairs! They also had beers on tap, for those of us not into whisky!
Best pizza in town.... Definately the BIGGEST....
I just visited Goodfellas Pizzeria for the first time. I had heard about the New York pizza ? they serve up and wanted to see for myself...Wow...I haven't tasted pizza this good since I had pizza in Queens in NYC in 1991 at a pizzeria in John Gotte's neighborhood.Great pizza. I will be back!
As usual it hit the spot. Stopped with my wife on the way to the airport. We both had a slice and a beer and chilled in the bar upstairs. We really appreciated the good pizza and friendly staff.
You have to visit the second floor of this place, they have the best Old Fashions, you can order your pizza from there as well. Awesome food, service and drinks!
Staff was friendly and helpful. Food was ready by the quoted time coming hot and fresh from the oven. And of course all the food tasted great
They had my order for 1 hour and only put in oven when I arrived!! Then they were rude. The insult is that my online order had a 10% tip!!!