Papa Johns Pizza

2511 E Center St, Warsaw - 46580
102 reviews
Pizza Chicken Wings Fast Food
(574) 269-3200

This location has been having a lot of trouble lately. The last two times we ordered, the tracking alerted us that our food was ready. We showed up and it wasn’t. Had to wait 15 min each time. We pick up our food today, got home (a 20 min drive) and saw that the garlic knots were dry. Just dry breadstick balls, no garlic butter. And there were only 6 with one smashed. Called in and they said they would remake them. Drove 20 min back and got the replacement knots. Almost left without checking while getting ready to pull out of the parking lot and we decided to check. NO garlic butter again! I thought someone was messing with us but nope. They were brought back in and we watched while they were done right this time. Holy cow so bad there.

I just started working here a couple weeks ago. The staff is friendly, hard working, very respectful to the customers, and most have been there for years so they know what they are doing and they know the area great and get the pizza's hot,fresh,and on time. I really enjoy working the management .They know there menu and have trained everyone very well. Fantastic atmosphere. I am really excited about working here.

Usually prefer dominos, but dominos in Warsaw can't seem to function so I went to Papa John's instead. So much faster, tastier, and overall nicer experience. Never going back to dominos again!!

Always fast and taste is almost nearly consistent. They have a good team here.

Food was okay. Placed an order online for delivery on accident I was able to call and get that switched to carry out which was great however they couldn’t return the delivery fee nor tip( which I was still considering leaving a tip just for a different amount) instead was told the girl there had an attitude over it and didn’t want to bother with it.

I found a long brown hair on my pizza , I called in and spoke to the manager and she told me that the only thing they could do was remake it ! I live 25 min away from this location and she told me there was absolutely no refunds ! Terrible management, terrible service , do not eat here unless you enjoy hair in your food !

The food is good. But they are very busy and the wait is quite long.

It was delicious loved the crust better than pizza hit crust, theirs sucked. Theirs used to be very good which now awfully.

This store is a mess! Called in took 38 minutes to place one order with 1 pizza and cheese sticks plus a second order with just bread sticks. Then when the orders was picked up that was a total mess up. Need to better train employees.

I was directed to somebody totally out of the store when I called, and then they must’ve only had one person working because it was going to be an hour and a half to two hours before I could even get a pizza. I had a store specific question about a complimentary pizza card so the random person on the other line that texts or emails orders into the store could not help me