This is the worst pizza I’ve ever had ??, the bread tasted rancid, the vegetables tasted like they just opened a can and pour over the pizza, it had a lot of tomato sauce and also tasted like can tomato, and the cheese was just a little in the center of it ?, and this was the works pizza , 6 toppings .we also had wings that tasted like Tyson frozen wings, just plain breaded with no sauce ?, both cost the same or more than peddlers so never going to order from them again.
If I could give 0 stars I would. The quality of this place has gone way down. I used to get pizza and bosco sticks from this location at lease 7 times a month. I will never go back. The pizza is under cooked. I got bosco sticks today and they were frozen still. When I called to let them know the older gentleman that normally answers was a complete d*ck. This Aurelio's is not good. I would not waste my money here ever again.
After a fishing trip back home, it was great to grab some pizza for the 3 hour trip back to Ft Wayne. Thanks to the great staff for offering paper plates & napkins when they found out !! YOU ROCKEver consider moving to Ftw where delicious pizza “ from the region” is desperately needed !!! ??
Normally don't write negative reviews but it's getting really old with the hit and miss with this location, Its either trash or semi good pizza. If you want good aurelios go to the one in portage 10 times better and they make it right everytime.
Love the crust, love the sauce! in my opinion it’s one of the best pizza places in Valpo.
I remember going to the original in Homewood IL, now that was PIZZA! I don't know what happened, I live just down the street from the Aurelio's in Valpo and still haven't been there. Judging from the reviews and seeing their prices I never will! You can't even order online and I downloaded their app and all it does is give you locations. Come on guys..."JOE" needs to pick it up a notch!
Got a large super six and was quite happy; the (few) negative reviews from other Aurelio's fans had me concerned but I thought them unfounded after tasting my order. My usual Aurelio's is that in Chicago's South Loop and this one was on point/comparable; will likely be returning in a few weeks!
Our FAVORITE pizza!! Quality service❤️
Great tasting local pizza.
When you drive an hour because you crave good pizza, you know its GOOD! ??