Piloni's Italian Restaurant

1733 Lafayette Ave, Terre Haute - 47804
247 reviews
Italian Wine Bar
(812) 466-4744

Went on a friday evening got seated just in time. There was a 4 hour wait after we were sat. I would highly recommend a reservation especially on a busy night. Got an appetizer it was good but not what i wanted. Tried a new chicken dish, it was good but i would not order it again. I would like to try a different one. All the food was hot and fresh. I love how the spaghetti is homemade. The meatballs are amazing too. Got cannolis for dessert they are delicious too! Everything we got was $70 for 2 appetizers 2 entrees and 2 desserts. I love this place i will always recommend it and i am always willing to go again.

Dined in during the early afternoon so there wasn't many customers which made it all the more enjoyable. We had heard good things but wanted to check it out ourselves. I saw the dish and expectations but it's totally blew my mind how delicious it was. My husband had the tortellini and I had a penne dish. Both were phenomenal! We had not been here before but after our first meal we will definitely be back! The lighting and ambiance created by the decorations provide an intimate setting that I enjoyed. Complimentary bread sticks were good. Overall a very delicious outing!

I give them 10 stars! Celi and Devin were delightful while they served up their scrumptious house made delicacies.

Ate here for the first time with a group of friends and this place didn't disappoint. I had the Chicken Alfredo and although it wasn't as good as the OG it was pretty good! The service was spot on never having to wait on a refill. The place is kind of small and can't get loud too. I will definitely be back.

We called ahead to check on availability on Valentine's weekend and they made some changes to seating to get us in. The woman on the phone was very courteous and personable. Upon arrival we were immediately greeted and seated by a man with a polite demeanor and a fantastic smile. Our waiter was enthusiastic and engaging without being intrusive. We did have an issue with my husband's entree and within moments the waiter noticed our hesitant behavior and insisted that the entree be made correctly. The replacement was at our table within five minutes! Try the desserts; they're great! Yes, the price was moderately up scale but the quality and serving size was well worth it. We WILL be returning soon!

Super good service and amazing food. It was my wife and I's first time here and I can safely say we will definitely be back in the future.

We are still eating but so.impressed had to be sure I made a review before forgetting. This place isn't fancy but it is it's nice casual but the food! Oh my word! We travel a great deal for husbands work and been near in every state and by far this is best Italian food I've had hands down. Truly home made Italian from noodles all the way to sauces you can tell every bite is made with love as they say. Will be back!

We drove about am hour to try this place. We will not be making that trip again. The breadsticks were dry, and all of our entrees needed salt. I am not one that usually adds salt either. The pasta was not quite done either. However, the service was very good and the food arrived in a timely manner. If you live closer, its worth checking out.

I love Piloni's. My order wasn't what I wanted but it was a very similar dish. That's what I get for ordering over the phone right before closing. It was still quite yummy though. Ordered again through DoorDash the next night and got the correct thing. We will be back.

This place is amazing. I ordered a Cesar salad and the croutons were amazing and the Cesar dressing is the best!! Legit Italian restaurant you can tell it’s homemade. Chicken Alfredo fettuccini is fresh and flavorful as well!