This pizza place is very close to my house, so to have this place practically around the block will surely pack on some extra calories in the future!My girlfriend and I walked inside and checked out the menu. We placed an order at the counter for a 1/4 Sheet Sicilian Pizza, Supreme style as it’s marked under Joe’s Favorite Pies. She got a Small Garden Salad. We were told it would be about 35 minutes, so we waited in our vehicle. It seemed we were only waiting about 15-20 minutes and the employee was bringing out our food. That was awesome for how quick it was done and awesome that they were kind enough to do so.We took our food home and dug in. The pizza itself already looked as if it was posing for the camera. The crust to it was nice and risen. There were plenty of toppings. They weren’t skimpy in that department. The sauce was very flavorful. I’d say the Sausage could have used a little bit of seasoning to bring out more flavor, but besides that it was close to a perfect pizza. Her salad was a good size for a small and for the price.The service was quick and to the point. They do have tables to sit at here, but I wouldn’t dine here myself as it’s too much of an open concept and clustered towards the entry. They do charge a Non Cash fee on the receipt, so beware of that!Overall, I recommend their pizza highly. I know I’ll be coming back very soon and probably over and over again after that.Date Of Visit: 6/21/22
This pizza place is very close to my house, so to have this place practically around the block will surely pack on some extra calories in the future! My girlfriend and I walked inside and checked out the menu. We placed an order at the counter for a 1/4 Sheet Sicilian Pizza, Supreme style as it’s marked under Joe’s Favorite Pies. She got a Small Garden Salad. We were told it would be about 35 minutes, so we waited in our vehicle. It seemed we were only waiting about 15-20 minutes and the employee was bringing out our food. That was awesome for how quick it was done and awesome that they were kind enough to do so. We took our food home and dug in. The pizza itself already looked as if it was posing for the camera. The crust to it was nice and risen. There were plenty of toppings. They weren’t skimpy in that department. The sauce was very flavorful. I’d say the Sausage could have used a little bit of seasoning to bring out more flavor, but besides that it was close to a perfect pizza. Her salad was a good size for a small and for the price. The service was quick and to the point. They do have tables to sit at here, but I wouldn’t dine here myself as it’s too much of an open concept and clustered towards the entry. They do charge a Non Cash fee on the receipt, so beware of that! Overall, I recommend their pizza highly. I know I’ll be coming back very soon and probably over and over again after that. Date Of Visit: 6/21/22
Pizza is normally one of our go to joints. However, this last time we ordered and they didn’t deliver the pizza and closed. Was ordered at 4 pm and they closed at 5….If you can’t deliver based on time, tell us and cancel.Very disappointed. Will go back to rosatis or Aurelio’s for awhile. We order pizza 4-5 x a month too.
Staff was unfriendly and unwilling to answer questions/offer recommendations. The pizza was undercooked after a 45 minute wait.
Solid sit down pizza for the family. Great alternative to carry out chains like Dominos, Pizza Hut or Papa John's. I'd definitely go here again.
I have had a lot of Pizza at tons of places, but tonight, Sicilian Joe's pizza is on point, by far the best pizza
Think this pizza is ok but what's up w/ the lack of sausage now a days. Must be the covid? Idk.
Delicious! We did the Tuesday $15 large pizza special and the whole family loved it.
The 10" pepperoni pizza was delicious. Their pepperonis have a small amount of black pepper on them, which adds a nice, but mild kick of flavor to the pizza. Crust was thin, as we prefer it. The spaghetti with garlic butter sauce was terrific. Super flavorful and less messy than a tomato-based sauce. The breadsticks could be improved upon, as they were too hard and not nearly as tasty as our other menu items. We'll definitely be back though for more of that pizza and spaghetti!
The best pizza in NWI!I really recommend!Hasta la vista baby