Barley Island Brewing Company

639 E Conner St, 639 Conner St, Noblesville - 46060
112 reviews
Pubs American
(317) 770-5280

Good food (tenderloin Tuesday) and our server Josh did a fantastic job.

Great music! And lots of great food and beer!

So disappointed... the previous time was very good but last night was not. We didn't get acknowledged at all even though the server told us to pick a table and saw us when passing by back and forth. They mentioned they didn't have enough staff and we were ok to wait longer until we realized that we'll get no service at all. We were hungry and were hoping to at least order something to eat first, we just needed to tell someone what we wanted... Didn't even need a menu and were willing to wait but were just sitting there until we gave up.

Strange place. The building seems to be an old hotel, and every seat in the bar area was taken (which was about 10 people). Yet everywhere else in the gigantic building was completely empty. So there was this weird juxtaposition of extremely full and the one tiny area, and extremely empty in the extremely large areas surrounding it. Not ideal... And it just felt kind of weird and creepy, and we left.

Strange place. The building seems to be an old hotel, and every seat in the bar area was taken (which was about 10 people). Yet everywhere else in the gigantic building was completely empty. So there was this weird juxtaposition of extremely full and the one tiny area, and extremely empty in the extremely large areas surrounding it. Not ideal... And it just felt kind of weird and creepy, and we left.

Great food, friendly environment. Love this place!

If I could give no stars I would. I had horrible service and thought I would try it again….bad idea. I had to go to bar asked to if we could sit anywhere then after 15 + minutes we finally had someone come to our table. Took our order…10 min later came back and asked our order again. Never once came back to check on us and had to go find our server to cash out. There was maybe 5 people in the restaurant. I don’t post reviews very often but the service was horrible.

We have (little) kids and this place makes it EASY to go out to dinner. The servers are always amazing and the drinks and food are awesome.

I love Barley!!! It’s one of the most awesome places to go to…!!! Great food, Wonderful service From Michael the bartender…. I did Have a little something that makes me think if I ever want to go back to a place that I loved so much. I got put out because I was drinking water and I got a seed caught so I nonchalantly got it up cleaned my mess which was just a little bit of water,…. And was told a I had to leave Not very happy with this person and it needs to be addressed but besides that I recommend totally

Best Brewery around! Not only is the beer fantastic but I challenge you to find a better pork tenderloin sandwich! And the staff is par excellence bar none! So nice to see Bobby again! If you haven't already try it and I'm sure you'll agree it's a great place to eat and drink!!