Tucker's American Favorites

2441 State St #6, New Albany - 47150
257 reviews
American Burgers
(812) 944-9999

Always great food!!! Everytime!!! Prices are decent, not cheap,but not expensive like almost everywhere else these days! I'd love to give a 5 star review, but in my experience the only thing lacking here is great service. Service is good... but not great!!! Really wish they would bring back the Florentine Chicken... that was my favorite dish!!!

My wife had the steak and said it was delicious. I had the loaded potato skins as an appetizer and boneless chicken wings. Both were good, but the wings were actually chicken tenders smothered in buffalo sauce, which I found hilarious. Our table was clean, but it seems like they only clean them when you're about to sit down. A lot of empty tables around us were dirty.

Blown away by our experience! $.75 wings on Tuesday! I have not been this excited by a meal in a very long time. It wasn't the price point, which wasn't bad at all, but the quality of service and food was phenomenal! From Ms. Amber and the amazing table service to the chef Mr. Cliff with mouth watering, hot - loaded fries and perfectly seasoned/sauced wings!Mind blown by our first experience here!

Me and some co workers came together to visit each other since we work from home now. Our waitress Amber was amazing. She never let any of our drinks go low. She was on it for sure and suck a very pleasant person.Our food was good as well. We enjoyed our time at Tuckers today. THANK YOU FOR SUCH A GREAT SERVICE .

Had a nice late lunch/early dinner. I have never been here before and I've lived in SoIN for over 10 years. The food was so delicious. My boyfriend and I ordered app combo platter, boneless wings (freaking huge) and 2 desserts to go, we were stuffed, but the desserts sounded phenomenal. And even after eating the take home food later, all of it was still delicious, that's hard to do!! We got fried oreos and butter cake. The bar tender came over to deliver a beer to me and told me I can try a few beers if I'd like to, I had inquired about beer flights after sitting down. We tried 3 different beers on the house!!! This restaurant has super friendly waitresses that are knowledgeable as well. I will definitely recommend this place to others!

This is one of my granddaughters favorite places, so whenever we go out to eat, this is where we usually go. We had the fried mushrooms to start. They were delicious. I had salad, steak and baked potato. My granddaughter had a cheeseburger and fries. Everything was delicious. Our waitress was right on top of everything.

Went tonight to try some of their ribs. Got seated right away and the waitress was nice. Appetizers took almost 35 minutes to come out. I had to go ask her if they were coming... (the place wasn't busy at all maybe at 30% capacity.) The entrees took another 20-30 minutes after that. $70+ meal the ribs were decent but the mashed potatoes were chunky not smooth and creamy with canned gravy. The mushrooms tasted like they were microwaved. Again the waitress was nice but the wait was so long. Probably won't be going back.

Just finished “eating.” Started off really well when we walked in and there was no wait to be seated! Now we know why. The food was absolutely awful. We started off with fried pickle spears which were fine. My boyfriend took one bite of his mashed potatoes and immediately spit them out and almost got sick. I ordered nachos with chicken and thought I had Covid (I dont) because I couldn’t taste it it was bland. I 10/10 do NOT recommend.

It was awful we heard good things about this place not sure if it would of been better if we had dined in or not but regardless spending $90 on a take out order the food should of still been edible. We have been sick for a week none of us really eating much we get our appetite back and wanted a good warm meal but didn't have the energy to really cook it ourselves. So we got take out it was awful my daughter's steak was supposed to be medium this thing was rare my ribs where cold and asked for extra sauce and my youngest daughters chicken was cold our 3 loaded potato had the topping for 1 potato divided between the 3 the queso was cold like right out of the fridge. What a waste of money McDonald's would of been better and that says alot and not to mention would of saved me about $70. I called today to speak to the manager she offered to credit me for 3 potato and the queso what a slap in the face.

There isn't anything spectacular on the menu that ever really makes me want to go here. The atmosphere is almost dingy, not in a dirty way per se, but just that it is old and needs an update. It's an ok place. They have a variety of burgers and sandwiches. My family loves their fried Ruben appetizers.