Agave & Rye

324 E Main St, New Albany - 47150
140 reviews
Tacos American
(812) 993-8226

I loved the setting. The wooden horse was pretty cool. Amy was my server and was very friendly. She walked me through the menu and pointed vegan options out to me. I had the faux Gen tso taco. It was tasty! The fries were perfectly cooked and hot when they came out. I like the idea of the red and green card to indicate if your just chillin (red) and don't need anything or the green side if you do. I ate in the patio and a couple young women brought their leashed dog so that's cool to know if I have my dog next time.

amazing food, atmosphere and service.

This is a cool alternative taco spot. The card on the table is amazing. Not having servers bothering you all the time but only when you need them is awesome. The staff is so diverse and the food is on point. They have an extensive list of bourbon and tequilas. Taco Tuesday is an awesome way to try out some tacos for a bit cheaper. Also the shirts are great. And yes, you should definitely buy one.

Amazing interaction with whole team for to-go meals and margaritas. Loved and will come back!

The food and atmosphere is incredible. I went for the birria tacos and definitely was not disappointed. Recommend it 10/10

Guaranteed happy taste buds! We love A+R and come out here specifically for the great service, delicious menu and fun decor. No two locations are the same. Tonight's visit to the New Albany site surpassed expectations. Kayleigh was such a joy and KNOWS her stuff. Me being a vegetarian and him being a carnivore, Kayleigh was able to help chose the best tacos to appease our pallets. I loved the Bang Bang and he loved the The Bomb. The elote is an absolute MUST no matter what! And warning...if you enjoy heat, get the Hibiscus Habanero Margarita. Its so beautiful, sweet but packs a serious punch!

Oh giva me some more Agave and Rye!!! Our walking group went her for lunch and oh my!! The best taco I have ever had and yes I have had many tacos! I had the plain Jane and it was a perfect epic regular taco! They have many kinds of tacos and next time I may venture out to one of the unusual ones. Also got their chips and queso.. and the queso was so cheesy and Not spicy.. exactly as I like it! Our server did a great job with a big group. They were busy and seemed to have lots of servers.. it felt like eating out BC (before Covid) Thank you Agave.. I will be back with more friends.

Literally the BEST taco I've ever eaten other than my wife's. I'll be back. Place was clean, staff was nice, sat at the bar but didn't drink(left a good size tip).

Love it! My parents introduced my husband and I to this restaurant a few weeks ago, and we can't wait to visit again. The flour and corn chips are amazing! Also the place is so beautiful one big photo op.

I had been wanting to try this restaurant for awhile, finally went, and glad I did! We ordered “The Yoda”, “Cousin Vinnie”, “Love Shack”, and “Sugar Daddy Plain Jane”, as well the the chips and queso. The taco’s were amazing, and all had different distinct flavors. The queso was delicious and thick with giant tortilla chips. We will be back to try more flavors! I also had the peach Bellini margarita and it was amazing.