Normally I would have given them a 5. I had never had a bad experience here until recently. Went for dinner with my family and friends, majority of us ordered steak. They advertise fishers meats and that sold us on getting steak. When the meal came three of our steaks were over cooked. My friend and I both ordered Ribeyes and the size of them was disappointing. Very thin and for a steak that is advertised at market price instead of a set price one would assume you would get a quality cut. When we informed the waitress she went to let the manager know. Upon returning she offered to discount the steaks. Not remake, just discount and apparently wanted us to continue eating our overcooked steak. The kicker here is that a 8 year old at our table had ordered a sirloin prior to our food arriving that looked like what I expected, larger, cooked nicely, and a good cut of meat. We ended up asking that they send the steaks back and cook us a sirloin. We receive the three steaks and my wife's is now undercooked. Instead of complaining more my wife decided to box it up and cook it more at home. Mine and my friends steak though cooked much better were bland. Not sure if the cook understands meat needs to be seasoned. Again, normally I would not have anything to complain about with Mulligans but this visit was a disaster. I will not be ordering steak anymore. Moral here: stick to the sandwiches.
Best restaurant in Muncie! Great service and better food
Great place for American food. We would definitely eat there again.Waitress did her job well, most of the food was cooked well with a good sear on the burger and the fried foods fried well. The tenderloin is giant and a great deal as is the double cheeseburger with bacon. The Hog was delicious. Some of the best fried pickle chips I've had (although I don't know if they buy them frozen).Their menu is quite large but some of the ingredients seem to be pretty good quality so I would feel comfortable ordering just about anything. They have some good looking healthier options as well.A few small things could have made it 5 stars: it was cold (this coming from somebody who hears their house to 68), the fries were not consistent, and the fries were the classically lame freezer bag crinkle cut.
Entire staff is great. Very good food selection and reasonably priced.
We LOVE it here. The atmosphere is laid back just like the decor. The food is wonderful with good flavor, portions, and cost. Would recommend. Also, if you're a parks and rec fan, I believe this is the restaurant that the writers based Ron Swanson's favorite restaurant on.
Service and food was great. Didn't wait long for dinner to be served.
Awesome service and their Mulligan was out of this world delicious
Want a fantastic breakfast? Try Mulligan's, you won't be sorry.
Good complete menu. We had lunch and each person in our group ordered a different item and all were pleased. The service was very good and the prices decent. This is an informal and comfortable atmosphere. Even with a few TVs on, the noise level was such that conversation was easy.
Very disappointed in food and service, gave them 3 tries and each time was awful! Bring back former management and cooks!