Vanilla Bean Bakery

West, 2324 W 86th St, Indianapolis - 46260
93 reviews
Custom Cakes Cupcakes
(317) 337-9470

We ordered 250 picture cookies for our event and they were beautiful and delicious! Kristy and Jim were great to work with from start to finish. I would highly recommend this darling small business. ( Stop in and treat yourself to some of their beautiful cupcakes. You’ll be glad you did?)

While the customer service was great the cupcakes and truffles were nothing but disappointing, they lack flavor. I ordered lemon, vanilla and oreo and they all pretty much taste the same nasty and lacking sugar and moisture. The one day I decided to have a cheat day and I’m the one who got cheated

I had a 80/90s themed girls night party and ordered a dozen cupcakes. We absolutely LOVED them and they tasted great. Kristy was so sweet. Thank you so much!

Vanilla bean bakery pulled through for us and delivered 5 adorable cookie decorating boxes to our door! The cookies were delicious and had everything we could need for decorating. We will definitely be using this bakery in the future! Thanks again!

Great customer service; patient and informative while I made my selection. Placing an order was easy and pickup was seamless. Our guests thoroughly enjoyed the gourmet cupcakes. We will certainly keep them in mind for future events.Recommended deal: Order 24 but pay for 20!

Amazing service and work! Very kind managers who were willing and ready to work with our huge order for our holiday party :) Highly recommend!

I had a cake emergency, and this place saved me!!! I called and was able to get six delicious mixed cupcakes and a batch of cake pops same day!! They were so nice, and it was all delicious!

I have tried to truffles, cookies and cake pops, they have always been super good. I got brownies the other day and I don’t know what to say other than wow! They were both Cakey and Fudgy. To me they were the perfect brownie. The only regret is that I don’t live closer, so that I could have these every day, Yum Yum!

First time visitor, but will not be the last. Wonderful cupcakes, the chocolate is amazing! Staff were very helpful and friendly.

The best of the best.I was introduced to the Vanilla Bean Bakery by our receptionist while I was spending time in our Indy office a few years back and they had catered in some holiday treats. I was so impressed that I ordered two dozen cookies to take back home with me for that year's holiday get together with my family. Finding any consensus amongst my family is not an easy task, but the one thing everyone agreed on was that I should have brought more of these cookies. Both kids and adults alike loved them.Ever since then, the cookies have been a staple of the family's Thanksgiving and Christmas feasts. Then Covid hit, my office closed in Indy and as we inched ever closer to Christmas I began to realize that there was little chance we'd be any near Indy this year to get our cookie order. Vanilla Bean's very own Kristy came to the rescue though. She went out of her way to accommodate our cookie order this year and get everything shipped right to our door. The cookies were beautiful as always and in perfect condition thanks to the care that was taken in packing them. Christmas is saved. Thanks again VBB, you're the best. See you again next year!