My family visited while staying in Indianapolis. My 6-year-old loves ice cream and his raspberry rumble in a cloud was a HUGE hit! I had the blackberry cheesecake, which was divine and my husband had a cookies and cream milkshake. He said it was chock full of cookie crumbles. TeeJay’s is drive up only, so expect a bit of wait. It is absolutely worth it, though! Visit Instagram or Facebook to get the daily list of flavors. We will definitely return to TeeJay’s on our next Indy trip.
Overrated- I bought the doughnut ice cream sandwich. To preface I LOVE desserts, I’ll eat and love most desserts. They use off brand weird tasting doughnuts, my kid also wouldn’t eat them. The ice cream was very basic and not creamy, or unique in any way. I could have bought ice cream and doughnuts from target and made it better for the same price and 6x the quantity. Not worth it, I won’t be returning.
Their brownies are AHHHMAZING!!!! Not to mention their ice cream is phenomenal! I love how they switch up flavors all the time! My new favorite ice cream spot for sure!
Great service, they do a great job at being speedy despite not having much staff. Specialty milkshakes are always great! Gentleman that took my order was friendly and good at giving suggestions for their menu. You can see the care and effort they put into running smoothly. An Indy most try spot, welcome to the NAP ?
Great place for some unique sweet treats! We recommend the Graham Central shake, cotton candy kiddie scoops, or anything else on the menu, because it is all pretty amazing.
?? gotta order the cotton candy burritoShakes are ???♦️♦️stay away from donut ice cream to my preference was just not good.To be honest I like Handel's or la michoacana better. But they have good creativity with the burrito.
Hey guys you wanna totally trash your diet?? This is the place to do just that! Quality and service were both excellent. My dinner choice was a donut sandwich with cookies and cream ice cream with gummy bears. Now I need to sleep this off and then go to the gym lol.
Greatest Ice Cream. Great Service.
Drivethru is an amazing option! Great ice cream and service! Definitely will be back.
Good ice cream. Only drive thru is open. Fast service