O'Reilly's Irish Bar & Restaurant

36 S Pennsylvania St, Indianapolis - 46204
178 reviews
Irish Pub
(317) 974-0674

I went here for a private party. The wait-staff was friendly and there were games to play. The food was decent... Not phenomenal, hence the 4 star rating. Typical "Irish" food, with everything being served with mashed potatoes. They didn't have any special or signature drinks here but their regular drinks were mixed fine. Not too bad size-wise, considering it's in downtown Indy and the decor fit in with the Irish bar theme. Overall, a pretty ok place to go with friends but nothing to rave about... Or complain about too much either.

Came in late night on Memorial Day as it was one of the only bars open in town. First time here and I brought a few of my staff--we just finished working the Indy 500. Joel took care of us, I'm not sure if he is the owner but he provided exceptional service and was the only person working that night. Would periodically stop by and check up on our group and brought our drinks out to us. Was super friendly and quick even though he had a lot of other people to take care of as well. Will definitely come back the next time I'm in town.

Joel was great! We came in and we’re greeted right away. I had my 3.5 year old with me and he brought his food early without me asking and brought him a coloring book while we waited! So thoughtful.Our beers were GREAT, service was fantastic, food was delicious and it all came out quickly! The burgers are soooo good!!!We are from out of town, but will definitely be back next time we are here!!

Great outdoor patio for people watchers and hands on owner !

Great service and staff, and the people you meet (locals and visitors) are just a gas. I go as often as I can.

We stopped in for a beer and dinner before the Elton John concert on 4/1. Wow! Great service! Our waitress recommended the meatloaf with gravy and it was so good. Very short wait for the food. Next time we come over from Ohio this will definitely be our dinner and beer choice!

By far one of the best experiences I have ever had. Joel and his staff are so welcoming and they take care of you the entire time. The food was amazing. The building is super clean. I definitely recommend highly and will be back if ever in Indy again.

Super friendly staff, great food & drinks. My favorite place in Indy!

Had a blast hanging with the crew here. Wasn't too crowded and they had a couple of dart boards for some friendly competition. Staff was awsome...those girls are brave handling any rowdy groups and kept the peace. Real pros. Food was not our objective but was surprisingly good.

Went here before a Pacers game and it was a huge disappointment. Wait staff seemed to be annoyed to even serve us despite the place but being terribly full. My veggie burger was burnt and it looks like the bun had gotten stuck to another one before coming out (at least I hope that was what was stuck all over the top of my bun). Left there feeling like I wasted my money.