Their pizza is delicious! Always fresh and hot at pick up. Their customer service is good too. They are very accommodating and caring people.
Amazing service! Delicious food prepared to perfection. True gem. Minority owned and operated.Mohammed greeted me with a smile, asked how we heard about them (we looked up places with good reviews). We are in town for the weekend for the race. I was concerned by poor reviews I saw on some other popular pizza chains, and I like to support local. This turned out to be a wise decision.We were immediately drawn to both the kebab pizza and chicken tika masala when looking at the menu online. We decided on the kebab. We ordered online, and I wasn't initially aware of an option to get half and half for two different specialty pizzas. Mohammed suggested that option for ordering next time.He opened the pizza box to show me and confirm accuracy of order. Everything was perfect! Pizza was ready within the estimated time window and hot. So glad we decided to give Magoo's a try while we were in town for the race. Good value for your money.Next time, we will request half and half so as to be able to try more variety.
Magoo’s is one of the best pizza places I’ve ever had. I have been having their pizzas for years and the consistency of their quality is unreal. Friendly staff, gets pretty busy so order over the phone ahead of time.Recommendations:Chicken tikka pizzaMeat lovers pizzaGet the garlic sauce on everything and ask them to spice it up.
Unsure of where you want pizza from or want to try something new? Read/look no further because you’ve found what you’re looking for. Magoo’s is top tier and I HIGHLY recommended the garlic sauce on your pizza instead of traditional sauce, you won’t regret it. Also don’t forget to grab yourself some of the homemade ranch, some of the best you’ll ever taste!
Very tasty halal pizza with a huge selection of toppings. Each pizza is made to order and will take some time if you’re eating in store. The staff is friendly and really care about each customer that comes through the door. The wings weren’t the greatest but everything else was delicious.
This place is so underrated! Highly recommend garlic sauce in lieu of pizza sauce (but both are great). Everyone who works here is very nice, it’s a clean place, and the food is delicious. Great pizza in an unassuming location. We’ll definitely add this place to our rotation and I’m looking forward to trying more things!
We had somewhat of a complicated order and several items. There was a bit of a wait but it was worth it. When he brought out our order he opened every single box to make sure we saw it and it was prepared the way we asked. Everything looked great. Then we started eating and everything was fresh and hot. No complaints here. This was my first time eating here and I was not let down. I highly recommend.
Pizza place I learn from a friend. I order Supreme Pizza to have a choice of tomato sauce or garlic sauce. I ask the gentleman what is the favorite for his customers,and I thought I would try it. To my surprise, I loved it,business was like a swinging door. Plan to attend again. Also, there's burgers,chicken wings, and a variety of other foods.
Simply put, this is the best pizza in Indianapolis!! We recently moved from the Eagle Creek area to Westfield, but I still happily drive the extra 45 minutes to pick up Magoo's. There is no other pizza place like it - authentic and unique styles, incredible ingredients, fantastic taste and awesome staff. Don't miss out on this delicious pizza!
The only place to get pizza in the entire state of Indiana! Ive traveled the world and this is top tier pizza. Definitely the one place I can eat em at everyday and not get tired of! We get the hot wings and meat lovercalzones every time, but you can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. Don’t forget to get the cookie or brownie pie!