Lovely lunch with friends at Catelloâs. We all ordered different things and everyone commented positively. Looking forward to returning.
We always enjoy lunch and dinner at Catelloâs. The food seems to get better and better. Ravioli Del Pescatore is absolutely delicious.
Es nuestro lugar favorito Todas los platillos que ofrece son fabulosos, la atencií³n espectacular y la calidez con que el dueí±o-chef se preocupa por todos es invaluable
I took my niece out for a birthday lunch. We ordered a cheese and meat tray, which was very good; salads, which were way too salty; and desserts, which were excellent. Our service could have been more attentive, especially since there were only two groups in the restaurant, but our waitress was new and just learning. The overall experience was good but could be improved.
Wry nice dinner. Great music.
From beginning to end, as always, Catello never disappoints! We had a visitor from Dallas and she was blown away by the food AND the entertainment!
Fantastic Experience and a True Hidden Gem! We have dined at the Catellos in Pendleton several times and happy to say that not only is the food every bit as fresh, authentic and consistently excellent at this new location. The atmosphere is upscale but comfortable and the selections of fresh pasta and his homemade burrata and mozzarella are Amazing. Among the very best restaurants in the city (and fortunately still a hidden gem). Definitely will be back every trip we have to Indy!
Excellent food! Excellent service - Jessica was wonderful! She make super perfect food recommendations and also made a great wine selection! Ambience was very nice. We do intend to return many times.
Great food and service
We sat at the bar. The bartender was only fairly well informed. I asked that the salads be served on a plate as the "bowl" makes it impossible to eat a salad. My gluten free pasta was not aldente. The menu did not fairly explain that the filet with pasta meant that the filet was diced and mixed with the pasta. There was no pistachio gelato although it is listed on the menu. The bartender said they didn't make any that particular Monday. My friend ordered the Little Italy gelato which was to be served with caramel sauce but wasn't. The bartender brought out a low end commercial syrup which we rejected. Perhaps because it was a Monday night the staff just wasn't what it should be especially not given the prices.