Bagel Fair

1300 E 86th St # 16, Indianapolis - 46240
107 reviews
Bagels
(317) 846-0950

Got a mixed dozen (13) and they're all really good. Quick, easy, and definitely better than chain store bagels. Gonna go back and get a sandwich for lunch!

Absolutely top tier quality bagels, the best I have ever tasted! And the service was amazing!

The freshest bagels, made ready to enjoy every morning. The simplistic style of this quick in and out bagel shop has a wonderful vibe and friendly energy about it.The Everything style bagel is my go to, and I genuinely enjoy the flavors of their fresh ingredients, either toasted or room temperature.Susan and the staff are a wonderful bunch, who take the time to ensure your food is prepared with care, tastes great, and that your experience is seamless and enjoyable.Thank you so much for your kindness, great food, and awesome vibes.See you next time ✌️

The best bagels any place. If you're lucky enough to get them still warm from the oven...........delicious

My awesome sister brings us these wonderful bagels to Michigan. The jalapeño cheddar cream cheese is absolutely amazing on a burger. The jalapeño bagels are great as well!

Price is $14 a dozen but still worth it. Counter only - no tables. Current hours reduced and they are open til they sell out - usually 1-2pm. No bacon for the hot sandwiches, only turkey sausages.

Amazing service!! I had to order a lot for work and they had everything ready and it was still warm when I got to the office. Everybody loved them. Best bagels in Indy!

After eating chain bagels for years, I finally went to a real bagel store. The difference was night and long lines out the door! I go a dozen of several kinds and they were all good!!

Some of the best bagels I’ve ever had! Closest to real NYC bagels I’ve found in Indiana. Highly highly recommend

This place has great bagels! The bagel fair makes their bagels in store meaning that they are fresh and great! I personally love their loc spread but they have all kinds! You can have them warm up the bagel and put a spread on it just buy some of their spreads and bagels for the upcoming week. You should definitely get some bagels from there.