This was my first time here and I was NOT disappointed. We got a large 2 topping pizza, order of breadsticks and 2L for a VERY affordable price. I had heard many good things about Aunt Polly's but for whatever reason had not tried it yet. I'm kicking myself for not going here sooner. The staff was also extremely nice and friendly. I felt right at home as soon as I arrived. I can't say enough good things about this place. I can't wait to go back and try their other items!
The food is excellent and the staff is very friendly, I ordered chicken wings and was expecting the skimpy wings like BWW serves, was I ever impressed, the wings are huge, and very good. My wife ordered a grilled chicken salad and she loved it. I highly recommend this food. We will be eating here again.
We are originally from the Chicago area so are kinda pizza snobs and perhaps a lil judgy concerning what is considered a "good" one...but we got into town late, we were hungry and wanted pizza. We found Aunt Polly's online and ordered since they deliver past 10pm.We definitely were NOT disappointed that we did!! Service was great, food was awesome (LOVED the sweetness of the sauce) and prices seemed reasonable.If we were local would order again!!!!
I spoke with April. She was very friendly and helpful over the phone even though it's past midnight. You could hear her smile over the phone.. I've never had a bad pizza, salad or experience when getting food delivered from them..they are deserving of a 5 star status..THANK YOU APRIL!?
We stopped in for dinner off of a suggestion from a waitress at a restaurant in Carmel. It was a little family run business and the pizza was amazing!!!! We stuffed ourselves! But set aside the pizza....the people were so amazingly kind, sweet, very friendly and just down to earth and genuine. Do yourself a favor and go grab a carryout from here! You will NOT be disappointed. We will be going back again.
First let me start off by saying I order Aunt Pollys so much and I have always lived it. Tonight when I placed an order I expected to get the same quality and service. I ordered my wings plain as usual with sauce on the side and they put barbecue and hot sauce on them. My breadsticks tasted like the yeast didn't rise and they were horrible. My Pizza was far from good and the dough tasted horrible. When I called to explain they asked me did I want to drive back and have them remake my wings. I stated that I wanted my whole order remade but my kids had already eaten some. The manager I spoke with was extremely rude and said to me " Do you know how many people call and try to get free food on their next order" . I NEVER once asked for Free food because I am more then capable of paying, I had just spend 30.00 plus. I only wanted my food remade. They lost my business for good. Horrible experience!!!!
First night in my new house and I don't have a refrigerator yet so decided to order something for dinner. It was already 12:20 am so I googled fast food close to me and Aunt Polly's was the closest to me so decided to give them a try. I ordered wings and onion rings. The young lady who answered the phone was very nice and polite. She told me it would be around 1 hour which was ok with me. Imagine my surprise when 20 minutes later there was a knock at my door. Another nice young lady was delivering my food, nice and hot. The wings are a nice size, lightly breaded and covered in hot sauce. The onion rings are quite crispy and nicely breaded, not to much breading as to not taste the onion but the perfect amount for my liking. I also asked for catsup and 2 small containers were included as well as a larger container with blue cheese dressing for my wings. Everything tasted good and the speed of delivery was a nice surprise. I'm glad I decided to give Aunt Polly's a call and even more glad they're just a stones throw up the road from my new residence. This will be my new go to spot when I want wings. Bravo Aunt Polly's!! I'm pretty particular about my wings and yours are spot on perfect for my taste.
I used to live in the area and order from here every couple of weeks. I just got it for the first time since moving and it did not disappoint. They have the best crust ever, I love their pizza sauce, and the bbq wings are so much better than I would have imagined. This place will always be a favorite of mine!
Just tried some calzones from Aunt Polly’s for the first time. They were great! I wold definitely recommend them.
Ordered pizza wings and breadsticks from here while we was Indianapolis and had great speedy service highly recommend