Stopped in for a really late lunch/early dinner today. It's nice having the option to buy by the slice. I know there is Luca and Enzo, but those places are complete and utter trash. Here, you can order by the slice, and customize the toppings to your taste. Most folks in the know will say that the key to a good pizza is the dough, but I disagree. NY Slice has pretty good dough, but for me, the key is the sauce, and they have pretty much nailed it. Not too sweet, not too spicy, and you get just the right amount. Got a couple of slices and a couple of the roni stix with cheese sauce, and I'm good for the day! Like most places these days, they seem to be having issues with finding people that want to work. Only one gentleman working when I was there, presumably the proprietor, and he was exceptionally friendly, despite having to do it all by himself. Definitely give this place a try, and give them a break if it takes a couple minutes longer than you'd like. It's worth the wait!
Best pizza we’ve had since our trip to Vegas! Service was great, the owner is super friendly. We stopped to just get a slice of pizza, and ended up going back to get a whole pizza. So glad we stopped!
Stopped by for lunch today. First time trying NY Slice. It was so good. I went in, the owner was working. He was extremely friendly and professional. Store was clean and the wonderful smell of fresh pizza filled the air. If you want pizza by the slice or a whole pizza, this place is great. Forget tge big chain pizza places. Support our local businesses!!
Wish it had been better! We didn’t realize it was basically a carry out place only. You could dine in, but they had very few seats. Wasn’t too big of a deal, as there was no one else in there. We had the regular breadsticks with cheese and garlic butter. I would have to say these were my favorite part of the meal, except for the one breadstick that had no seasoning on it…that was kinda disappointing! I loved the seasoning on them! The cheese was tasty and the garlic butter was good too! Our pizza took twice as long to come out as it should have. Not sure why. My hubby had pepperoni and banana peppers on his. Sadly it looked like the peppers were an afterthought…they didn’t look or taste like they’d been baked on the pizza, but rather thrown on afterwards. I had a plain pepperoni slice and one with pepperoni and sausage. They were decently good, but it was nothing special. To me the pizza had little taste and very little sauce, plus the sausage looked undercooked, but I’m sure it was a actually fine….just not pleasant to look at! It wasn’t bad bad, just not our cup of tea. Everyone has different tastes and likes, so at least give it a try if you’re a pizza lover!!
I needed to take a moment and let the public know about this amazing pizzeria. As a native New Yorker, this is the closest(if not spot on) to New York pizza here in Indiana. It is so good that I drive down from the Carmel area just to get a pie! That's a 40+ minute drive just for pizza. I even purchased one of those pizza warming cases so the pizza stays hot until I get home. "Why go through such lengths?", you may ask. It's the pizza is just that good. The owner is super cool and has a background as a chef. He even gets the science of making the pizza (how shocking the water at various levels can alter the dough quality). I hope you get to meet him when you place your order, and I highly recommend ordering from NYSlice for your pizza fix.
I needed to take a moment and let the public know about this amazing pizzeria. As a native New Yorker, this is the closest(if not spot on) to New York pizza here in Indiana. It is so good that I drive down from the Carmel area just to get a pie! That's a 40+ minute drive just for pizza. I even purchased one of those pizza warming cases so the pizza stays hot until I get home. "Why go through such lengths?", you may ask. It's the pizza is just that good. The owner is super cool and has a background as a chef. He even gets the science of making the pizza (how shocking the water at various levels can alter the dough quality). I hope you get to meet him when you place your order, and I highly recommend ordering from NYSlice for your pizza fix.
The location in Greenwood was very clean, the timing of our food was really fast even though there was only one gentleman there at the moment and the pricing was very fair. It was absolutely delicious the pizza was loaded and all I had was a slice it had more toppings on it than some pizza pies come with. They have a return customer out of me.
This pizza is the truth! So delicious! I rank it #1 in my book. Authentic East Coast! The young man forgot to add my individual slice on my to go order. I called in and the owner (such a gentleman), answered and I told him my problem. He said " ok, it will be on me!" He also would not take a tip. He said "we all have to eat , we're all family. " I am very impressed by his humanity which exemplifies his delicious pizza! I got sausage and pepperoni today. Enjoy your self when you go. You will be satisfied.
Pizza was very good. The customer service was fantastic! I didn't realize I had not added a topping when I ordered on their website. When I went in to pick up my pie, I noticed it was missing and was confused. I realized I didn't put the topping on the pizza because I assumed it came on it. They swiftly put the topping on it for me and popped it back in the oven for a few minutes to get the pepperoni warm all at no extra charge. I told them repeatedly not to worry about it, then that I was willing to pay the extra that they were entitled to. They did not want the couple of dollars, just to make sure I got what I wanted. Thank you and I will be back!
The pizza was absolutely amazing. Ordered a large pepperoni and it was perfect. Nice crispy crust with incredible toppings. Definitely will be my go to spot in the future ? (the staff were extremely nice as well)