Gallagher's Pizza

1273 N Bluff Rd #7748, Greenwood - 46142
185 reviews
Pizza
(317) 883-3334

My husband and I decided to try their pizza for lunch one day since we had heard great things. We loved it so much we ordered for my sons 1st bday party the next weekend! Everyone raved about the pizza and the staff was so nice and accommodating. I always love supporting local businesses and this is one I would highly recommend!

Went in and ordered a medium pizza with bacon that was $19 and some cents. Waited 25 mins and Ended up getting a pizza with sausage and pepperoni instead and I really hate the taste of sausage and I’m not a big pepperoni fan either, but it was hard to tell since it was under the cheese under I pulled the first piece… I didn’t have the time to wait another 25mins for the correct one, but they were so dead that I don’t know how they even screwed up my order in the first place. Very disappointed

I had never heard of a Pizza named "The Kitchen Sink" - Mouth watering expectation every time!

Where to start, I tried a pizza called the sink, and wow!!! If you like everything on a pizza you will love this. What made is special is the crust is not soggy like most when piled on. There’s pineapple and jalapeño which works. I absolutely love this pizza

100 degrees in there. Phones ringing off the hook. Ridiculous waiting. Decent pizza is if have an entire afternoon to deal with the high school kids who could care less. Just order something with delivery. Door dash won't even touch this place. Been standing here for 20 mins for a call in oder pure trash.

Firstly, I like to support & buy local businesses. But one has to "call a Spade, a Spade". One of my food guilty pleasures are pizza & BBQ joints. Thus, I thought I try this local pizza joint.The service staff is very nice & friendly. However, like MANY pizza lovers out there from the various posted reviews, I find the large Sausage pizza to be very bland & lacking any layers of flavor (the pizza sauce is the key to great pizza). Even the sausage itself is NOTHING to write home about NOR rave about. Unless, you possess the geriatric pallet of NO tastebuds & like your food bland. I've been very fortunate to have vacationed in Italy & this pizza would rank VERY low on its pizza taste scale i.e. lacking in savory layers of flavor.Notice the constructive criticism of how to improve the pizza. And NOT "slamming" it for the sake of being cruel, inhumane, & unconstructive. My gosh the pizza weighs a ton due the cheese content. But even the cheese lacks any flavor. Maybe I caught this pizza shop on a bad night. I will try it one more time this summer after this posting to see & experience any positive changes/ results...a future followup review pending.

Worst pizza and wings I’ve ever had. I’d rather eat cardboard with sauce and cheese than this. The wings are so soggy, it’s like that were sitting in water and they put wing sauce on them. Bonus ! it was expensive too ! Would not recommend ever.

I normally don't right reviews but I seen a couple 1 star ratings slamming this place. I don't agree me and my wife love it! We order the kitchen sink. We used to order from the extraordinary pizza in Wannamaker but we moved. Very similar both awesome pizza's if you like everything on it (jalapenos on the side)!! Keep up the good work!!

The owner is very nice, but the pizza is honestly horrible. It is probably one of the most bland pizzas I have ever had. I typically try to support small businesses, but the crust has a very cardboard texture to it, the sauce has absolutely no flavor and you could peel the entire topping of cheese Off with one single corner. The prices are way higher than they should be for this low grade pizza. It literally tastes like they poured tomato paste on a piece of jacks pizza and put one single slice of cheese on it. They definitely need to revamp their recipe. Wouldn’t recommend.

This was our 1st and last time ordering from here. Pizza and wings sucked?