New York Plate

5808 Melton Rd #2905, Gary - 46403
125 reviews
Comfort Food Seafood Mediterranean
(219) 939-8800

We absolutely loved finding this place. It's not shiny or flashy, it was kind of hidden but the taste of the food, the size of the portions, and the price per meal made it an amazing experience. If you go you have to make sure to try the Cheetos Menu and those Mozzarella sticks with the cheese dip makes my mouth water just thinking about it. The portions were huge and well worth the money spent on it. If we drive thru there again, we will definitely be stopping.

Food was good but the girl at the counter spoke so softly i could barely hear her

They deserve no stars this restaurant is horrible. They’re not even putting steak in their meals that are supposed to have steak they’re advertised steak but instead it’s substituted with Gyro meat. I ate some of the food started feeling sick because the hummus was no good and was throwing up most of the night

First time stopping here very polite fast service and amazing delicious food most definitely would drive all the way from Chicago just to eat here again

I order the fish and chicken on the sign states 3 and 3 when I got my food it was 2 and 3 the fish tasted spoiled I take it back and the manger lied told me I was and hour late picking up my food and that’s why it was like that. HORRIBLE I WILL NEVER GO BACK TO THEM AGAIN.

Will only take orders walk in. I have 7 to 10 orders from mill. Called to order ahead of time was told no. Then I get there to order and given attitude. Will not happen again. Will make sure everyone at mill knows to. Just lost a lot of business.

amazing food wow the plates will feed two people easily staff was amazing prices are great

100% perfect. From the service to the food, this place has it all. Amazing FAT plates of deliciousness.

Delicious food on a very unique menu I had a Brooklyn plate with steak chicken and gyro it was amazing

Had one of the best phillys in my life loved it and will be back