The Old Custard Stand

9270 E 141st St, Fishers - 46038
133 reviews
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt American
(317) 776-3800

Always a good place to have some ice cream. Love the outdoor seating. Very easy to get in and out.

I have been coming here for many years. This is our go to custard/ice cream joint. I have always supported local owned and operated but this is not just support. This place is tried true and local. Never have I had a bad experience… staff super friendly. Only wish they were open 365 days. We go once a week while in season.YOU MUST TRY worth the trip! Will not disappoint!

Awesome custard and very friendly staff! The shortcake sundaes are excellent!

Best custard, love all the different flavors. Everyone is always friendly.

Nice outdoor seating. Chicken salad was good. My aunt enjoyed her taco in a bag, her first ever. Glad we could enjoy a meal together here.

Best Ice Cream place in Hamilton County, hands down. I've been coming here for 15+ years, and there's not a single time I've ever been disappointed. 1000/10

This is one of the best custard ice cream we’ve had - this beats out Culver’s . Love supporting local business - the sandwiches here are good too ! I recommend the tuna salad sandwich .

The Old Custard Stand has the best flavored sodas in town!! It's our favorite seasonal go-to.

I have never eaten here before until today. I ordered a chicken salad sandwich and onions rings. The onion rings were homemade and so was the chicken salad. Both were the best I've ever had and the price was right! I will definitely go back.

The perfect summer spot for frozen treats and my favorite taco in a bag but everything i have had has been very good this is our go to spot