Jimmy John's

13272 Market Square Dr Suite 105, Fishers - 46038
57 reviews
Sandwich Shop Fast Food
(317) 288-7420

We got 3 sandwiches turkey, club and tuna…the turkey and club were great but there couldn’t of been more than a tablespoon of tuna on the tuna sandwich…it was like eating a loaf of bread with tuna flavoring

Ordered “freaky fast delivery”, but their driver had quit 3 hours prior and sadly they accepted my order… When I called, the child on the phone literally stated it wasn’t their fault. Avoid this one!

This location is terrible.... first visit was at lunch time and the bread was hard as a rock, definitely a day or two old. Not to mention drive thru took forever Came back today (months after first visit) asked to add hot peppers, literally got 3 peppers on my sandwich. I can understand not wanting to load up the sandwich with extras but 3? May as well have left them off completely. Bread was also nice and hard yet again.And a price increase to top it all off?? There are many other, better, options for lunch over this place for the same priceComing here again was mistake on my part, a mistake I won't be makin l a third time.

One of my favorites. Good service, great food and a great experience.

The best sub in town: spicy east coast Italian

Sandwiches are usually fine but this is by far the slowest Jimmy Johns location. If you're local and order delivery from this spot, expect +45min. My advice: Don't tip ahead

#1 Pepe the best! Fast and kind and clean!

Terrible covid related customer service issue. I never leave reviews but this was unsettling.

Consistently the slowest jimmy johns ive been to

The worst Jimmy Johns. Ever. The only reason I'm giving 2 stars is because there is 1 guy that works there who is awesome, friendly and appreciative. When he isn't working, you can expect such slow delivery you will "freak" that it takes an hour. And don't ever order your sandwich differently then as it comes because there's a 95% chance you won't get it, and 99% if there is an upcharge.