Little Italy Restaurant

4430 N First Ave, Evansville - 47710
208 reviews
Italian Pizza Pasta Shops
(812) 401-0588

My husband, son and I wanted to try this restaurant out. We pass by it often. This evening we finally went in to dine. I was very impressed with the food. It was excellent. The atmosphere is very calm and relaxing. Our waitress was very friendly. We will definitely be going back. We definitely recommend it to anyone looking to have some delicious Italian food.

We waited to be seated after giving the host/manager our name, he seated a party that gave the host their names after us before us while we waited longer, after we were finally seated the service was not great, the waitresses not on top of anything at all and it took forever to get anything, drinks, bread, food, service, etc. The food was not impressive but it wasn’t bad, I’ve eaten better Italian at other Evansville establishments. Over all I’d say it is a 5/10. This was our first experience there.

Excellent food! So rich with flavors! Highly recommend!

WOW!! This place is amazing! Warm atmosphere with fireplace, very friendly staff, great menu options, AND IMPECCABLE FOOD!! The absolute best Alfredo I’ve ever had. Spot on tiramisu. My husband and I were visiting Evansville and stopped here on a whim, and I’m super glad we did! If in the area, and looking for authentic homemade Italian, this place is a must. Sorry to rave... but I wish we lived closer.

Very friendly waitress. She did her best to take care of the customers. Our food? I would give it two stars. We ordered fried green tomatoes, they were not fried, they were burnt! Our Mediterranean salads were very simple, mine only had one black olive, the greens were not very Mediterranean, just lettuce, a few tomatoes, some cheese and dressing. I can't say anything about the pasta or pizza, we didn't try either, but people were ordering both.

My wife and I really enjoyed the friendly and comfortable atmosphere here. Family type setting very clean service was great and food was amazing! If we're ever in the area again we wouldn't hesitate to visit again! Loved the fried zucchini

Great food and great people. We order every couple weeks and they remembered that my wife had an allergy despite the point that I forgot to mention it when I ordered her dinner. Very thankful for the owner and his son's attention to customer service.

Don’t know about the food but we called to ask if you needed a reservation as it was a Saturday evening (4:30 pm). We were told no reservation needed and that they would take a walk in. We were told it would probably be a 25 minute wait. So we immediately drive over this place which is 6-7 miles out of the way, and get there only to be asked if we have a reservation. Then were told that we needed a reservation & that the reservations were full for the night. Just tell me that when I call before I drive to the restaurant!!!

The staff are really great. The owner is very friendly. They all make sure that you are taken care if.

My favorite feel good place to eat. Delicious salad. Well, delicious everything and good service. Relaxing, comfortable atmosphere.