Hornville Tavern

2607 W Baseline Rd, Evansville - 47720
149 reviews
Bar & Grill American
(812) 963-0967

Food is good. However, I ordered 35 meals for a family get together. I had asked for the price to include tax and everything and didn't want any surprises. I was quoted 11.99 per meal. That should have come to $419.65. When the food was picked up the bill came to $534.80! SUPRISE! I could have lived with the $33.57 sales tax but they also tagged on $81.58 gratuity. This was NOT catered. It was picked up and when ordered requested quote to include EVERYTHING. When I called to inquire about, the manager would not refund any additional I paid above what she quoted me. I even offered to settle for half the amount but she said no. Her attitude was very unpleasant and unprofessional. Never order from them again.

Prime rib was awesome. Good service

A hidden gem! Really enjoyed our trip to Hornville Tavern. Went in for lunch and got the fried appetizer platter and it was huge with lots of selection. Finished lunched with a delicious double cheeseburger and fries. Everything was very reasonably priced, would definitely recommend, and look forward to going back.

Our first time since COVID hit, Riley steak was cooked to perfection. Baked potato and salad were good. Excellent service!

We had a great experience. Great environment, great drinks, and great service. Destiny was a wonderful host and took great care of us!!

Excellent, energetic service and equally fine diner/tavern style food. The pulled pork sandwich and smoked chicken entres were delicious. The mashed potatoes appear to be instant and not real.

Delicious dinner! Great service!

We are traveling through from Nebraska so we thought we would stop to eat. I would not recommend this place to anyone!! We waited 2 and half hours for food and when we got the food it was cold ! When I told the waitress it was cold her response was im sorry I'll heat it up myself. ... food was horrible and service was soooo bad . I would eat garbage out of the trash before I ate here.

My husband and I celebrated our 3 year wedding anniversary and decided we had to try their pork chops. Such a good decision! Their pork chops are amazing and their service was awesome too! Will definitely be back!

One of the best places on earth. Go for a ballgame, sit down dinner or both. Food delicious!!! Service, OFF THE CHARTS GOOD!!!! Stacy and Matt were amazing. I will be back as soon as possible. Thanks for having me as a guest.