I got a large deep pan sausage and pepperoni and a large sausage thin crust, it comes with a free small cheese pan. Ingredients were not fresh. Thin crust had almost no sauce and and pan pizzas were undercooked. Not to mention sausage was under seasoned.I wasted 58$ I’m so disappointed.
Looking for a family owned pizza place. Saw the reviews figured I’d give it a shot. Owner talked the talk but he walked the walk. Pizza was great. You do pay more but you can’t put a price on quality. Will recommend family & friends. Well done Pizza Cellar.
Great pan pizza, the best local pizza I’ve had and I’ve tried several!????????
Tried Pizza Cellar on a friend’s recommendation. Absolutely delicious chow. The crust is a pleasing amalgam of buttery crumb and crispy edge. The sauce is complex and nicely balances sweetness, acid, and herbaceousness. The homemade sausage is a medley of quality pork and spices that makes the sausage at competing pizza joints seem like swill. The fresh ingredients are superb, as is the caramelization the cooks put on the cheese. Yet somehow, this vastly superior pizza is just a few dollars more than the “discount” pizza restaurants. What’s more, Pizza Cellar’s Italian beef and Italian sausage sandwiches are the very best in town. Just order extra jus on account of they’re big. Whatever you order, you will NOT be disappointed!
Hands down the best pizza in Northwest Indiana!! Closest thing to the pizza joints in Chicago that are the best!! The owner takes pride in his food and it shows!!
Their pizza is one of the best in town!
Omg!!! Just ordered a sausage and pepper sandwich. Delicious and huge! Thank you, Tony!
Tried Pizza Cellar on a friend’s recommendation. Absolutely delicious chow. The crust is a pleasing amalgam of buttery crumb and crispy edge. The sauce is complex and nicely balances sweetness, acid, and herbaceousness. The homemade sausage is a medley of quality pork and spices that makes the sausage at competing pizza joints seem like swill. The fresh ingredients are superb, as is the caramelization the cooks put on the cheese. Yet somehow, this vastly superior pizza is just a few dollars more than the “discount” pizza restaurants. You will not be disappointed!
Awesome pan pizza! Quick and delicious. We took advantage of the special - got 2 mediums and received 1 small pan for free. The pan was a bit better than the thin crust. Sausage tasted top quality. Very tasty sauce. Good amount of cheese. Highly recommend.
Wrong pizza delivered......was swapped with another customer. Driver offered to swap them back.....after they had already been delivered for some time! Called pizza cellar and the only remedy offered was a refund.