The Old Spaghetti Factory

918 S Rangeline Rd, Carmel - 46032
245 reviews
Italian Caterers
(317) 708-9669

Always fun!

I had a below average experience here. First, the place is decorated really uniquely and has a lot of options for where to dine including in a train car or next to a window in cozy lounger chairs. They have comfortable seating options for every size group. Unfortunately the service and food were lacking. It must have been our waiter's first day because he was slow, not knowledgeable on the menu and never cleaned our table up, even when a glass of water was spilled all over the place. The food was just alright. I got the Tuscan meatballs which were tiny compared to other restaurant's serving sizes. The salad was bland and the bread was just okay. Plus prices are on the high side. Overall, this was a bit of a disappointing first experience at this spot.

Whoa that garlic cheese bread was so soft and delicious! Great food, fantastic decor with an old trolley car built into seating. Can't wait to go back!

Been here 2 times because my 16 year old loves this place. I can say that this place is 5 times better than an olive garden and appreciate the fresh sauces and perfectly cooked pasta. The environment in the restaurant is A+. Definitely a fun and delicious time.

Service was good but felt rushed. We were still eating our dinner when they brought out the spumoni. It was a week night and they were not busy so there should not have been a rush to turn their table around.

Wonderful atmosphere. Great food. Very enjoyable

Best pasta dishes. Love their hat stuffed green pastas and Alfredo dishes. Great service and good prices. Recommended.

Food was great. The experience wasn't as great. It was not busy at all and unfortunately the service was sub par.

I ordered to go. The food was good however the amount of sauce is minimal. I called and asked why the amount was so little and they explained they give you 2 oz of sauce on the pasta. That's 4 tablespoons of sauce.... she offered to give me $8 of the $18 that it cost me. I'm just sad that this place went down hill.

Very disorganized staff, our reservation was lost. Waitress was very friendly. Food quality was very very underwhelming.Had a few items that we ordered, but were told after the fact, were not available.