The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers, Carmel City Center

799 Hanover Place, Upper Deck, Hanover Place Suite 260, Carmel - 46032
960 reviews
American
(317) 257-2253

Gave this a 3 star review on Yelp BUT somehow my review disappeared. Considered buying some macrons BUT there was a fly crawling on them. When I told the gal about it, she said that there was nothing they could do about them...gross! Especially for what they charge for their products. Bought a slice of cake and a card for $23...wow, pricey...especially since the cake was dry. Although the service was wonderful and the gal was super kind, this place is overrated and not really worth the exorbitant cost.

I made reservations 3 weeks ahead of time. When we arrived at 3:00 we were seated on the porch even though the day was almost 90 degrees. Since it was the middle of the day I assumed that the air conditioned part of the restaurant must be full. But after about 30 minutes I went to the bathroom and found that a whole air conditioned section was empty. And no one was seated there during our visit. Why would such an upscale establishment treat guests with a reservation so poorly? We weren’t given a choice if we wanted to sit on the porch. It was miserable.

Absolutely amazing. 10 out of 5! Food, service, and vibe were all outstanding.

This was a beautiful shop, the parking and space of the bakery is wonderful compared to the broad ripple location. Yes the bill will be high however most of their stuff is high quality and priced fairly! Some things are not however you will still be happy with the service and I think it can be a memorable experience.

Amazing atmosphere! One thing I can promise is that I will be going to Cake Bake until I DIEEEEEE!!!

Had the lemon shake up to drink. It was a ton of ice and tasted like all lemon juice…not good. Salad was just ok. In my opinion the cakes are beautiful but taste is just okay. The service was just okay. Our server greeted us and then we didn’t see her again for 20 minutes. It’s beautiful and we went because it was a special occasion but really not worth the $200 for lunch for 3 adults.

So magical!! I love going to Cake Bake. Everything is always outstanding.

Great way to celebrate with the one’s you love! ❤️❤️❤️

Our server what outstanding; the other staff was excellent

Wonderful trip! Loved it all!! Can’t wait to go back!!